By
Viewed
2,903,643
Please choose the correct answer for each question below:
Questions: 0/364
Correct: 0
Translate:
- There is a growing movement
over the past couple years
that at first seems kind of backwards,
but then the more you think about it,
it actually does start
to make a lot of sense.
It's dumb phones,
a phone that just goes back to the basics
and does exactly what you
need and nothing more,
'cause clearly we need to
spend less time staring
at these colorful glowing boxes
and go outside and touch grass, right?
(air whooshing)
So, okay, it's 2025,
smartphones do everything,
they're amazing,
and they have been for a while.
And I think we all agree
that they're a net positive for humanity.
They're incredible at connecting
people across the globe.
They give us access to
information everywhere.
They've revolutionized modern photography,
they've created entire
new economies around them.
Amazing.
But along with all of that good comes
some trade offs naturally,
and one of the biggest ones
is that they're designed
to keep your attention
and to be addicting.
There are apps that literally,
their sole purpose is to
maximize your screen time,
to send you distracting
notifications to hook you back in
and just give you little
strategic hits of dopamine here
and there to keep you plugged
in as long as possible.
So, the idea is simple.
What if we just took
all of that extra stuff
and took it outta the smartphone
and just left you with
exactly what you need?
And if that sounds familiar,
it's because I talked about this in depth
in my BOOX Palma review.
I'll link it below that Like button
if you wanna check that out.
But yeah, this concept isn't exactly new,
but this particular phone
is the most interesting
version I've seen yet.
This feels like if someone
was assigned a task
of designing a dumb phone
that a smartphone lover like me
would still be tempted to use,
then this is about what they would make.
(gentle electronic beep)
So, all right, we gotta talk
about this Light Phone III.
So, in the spectrum of dumb phones,
this one is definitely the
most premium-feeling one,
like this is the one that
will feel the most at home
for regular smartphone users.
So, maybe you've seen some of
the others in this category,
like the BOOX Palma,
or now the BOOX Palma 2
that I've been testing,
or even this one.
This is called the Minimal Phone,
which has an E-Ink display as
well, and a physical keyboard.
There was also the Light Phone II
and the Light Phone I before this,
but the Light Phone III I
was immediately drawn to.
It's not E-Ink,
this is an OLED display under matte glass
and it's wrapped in this all-metal body.
So, it's this cool little all-black box
with big, clicky buttons around it.
The bottom of the front here
is this large speaker grill,
which throws me back
to the HTC One M8 days,
and on the left side
is actually this nice dial that rotates.
Like, this is nice.
It's got these nice flat sides, obviously,
the buttons are clicky and built well.
The whole thing, it's just nice to hold.
And so then it's got this
button on top you use
to turn it on,
and then you hit that
button to go into the UI
and it's this nice, clean UI.
All-black background, thin, white text,
just the time and the battery at the top.
Then, like I said,
this button on the right
always takes you home,
and this is your UI.
Just text labels of the
different essential things
that it does.
This is the part where I age myself
and I ask if anyone else
remembers the Zune HD.
If you don't, do yourself a
favor and Google it real quick.
Pull up another tab, check that out.
You might end up wanting one,
but you can't have one
because it's 16 years old,
so close that tab, come back here.
Okay, this is the primo in
minimal phone experience,
even nice little touches like this dial
on the left hand side.
If you turn that,
that's your brightness
adjustment anytime you want.
And then if you push it in,
that turns on the flashlight.
It's convenient.
And then it does have a
SIM card tray right here,
so you can make phone
calls and save contacts.
And then you can see the
other things it's capable of,
of course, setting alarms,
everybody needs that.
There's a calculator and a
calendar, there's a camera,
which, as you can see,
activates the single camera on the back.
It's got this dedicated
two-stage shutter button.
Now, it's not a good
camera, but it is a camera.
You can't change aspect
ratio or resolution,
or do portrait mode or anything like that,
but it is definitely a camera.
I scroll to my second page
and you can see I have the Maps app,
which actually does
turn-by-turn directions,
walking or driving.
And there's also a podcast experience,
which is super basic, but
that's all it has to be.
It's functional,
let's use subscribe to podcasts
and listen to them on the fly.
And you can even pair
Bluetooth headphones to this.
Now, if you ever wanna
add or remove any apps,
you actually can't do that on the phone.
You can reorder them,
but if you ever wanna add or remove any,
you have to go to the online dashboard,
and this gets set up right
when you get the Light Phone.
But through here,
you can click into the Toolbox section
and then you can add or remove tools
from the Toolbox is what they call it.
So, the ones I don't have on
this phone here are Directory,
which is a contacts list, Hotspot,
Music, Notes, and Timer.
And if I wanted to add one,
all I'd do is click on it and hit Install
and it appears on the
phone in a couple seconds.
And I love the idea of this.
This is such a neat, just a
neat little piece of hardware.
It's like a little, it's a
conversation starter too.
Like, if you ask me, like I said,
to design a minimal
phone piece of hardware
that's like half the
size of a normal phone,
it's just a nice thing to hold.
I like this, I like this a lot.
And E-Ink, E-Ink was cool
on a lot of those other minimal phones
because obviously the
legendary battery life
and that readability and
all those other conditions,
but I actually think I prefer this
in most indoor lighting situations anyway.
It's just, it feels more premium
and it can do all the same stuff.
But yet there is no TikTok,
there is no Twitter on this
phone, there is no Instagram,
there is no email,
there is no web browser,
there are no third-party apps,
no notifications other
than texts and calls.
I will never waste my time on this phone.
Unfortunately, once you
actually try to use this phone,
that is the exact moment
that it goes from being a really cool idea
to really frustrating.
(notification beeping)
So, okay, let's say I'm at the studio
and I have a calendar event
in an hour in the city
and I wanna navigate there.
I can actually put a location
in the calendar event,
but I can't click on it to navigate.
And so, you might think,
"Okay, just copy and paste it,"
but this phone doesn't seem
to have copy and paste either.
So, you gotta go ahead
and manually flip over
to the Directions app
and then start typing away.
And good luck, because there's
no auto-correct either.
So, you're gonna want to double check
and get this address exactly right
with no multitasking
feature to help you out.
If I go to pay for something
at the local bistro while I'm there,
I can't pay with my
mobile wallet like I would
with a smartphone, even though
it does actually have NFC.
Okay, not a big deal,
I guess I can break out the
old fashioned physical card,
and also the vibration motor's pretty bad,
which makes me sad.
Also, that top button is supposed
to be a fingerprint reader
to lock and unlock as well,
but that doesn't work yet.
I also would've liked
a nice scroll animation between pages,
just as a subtle nod to
maybe even like the Zune HD,
maybe some nice scrolling physics.
It is OLED after all, but I don't know,
maybe scrolling is too triggering
or just feels like it
reminds you of TikTok,
so they don't do that.
There is no ebook reader at all,
which maybe just feels like it's missing,
because so many other dumb
phones do have reader apps.
But I guess it's a natural
fit on all of those
because most of them are E-Ink displays,
which are perfect for reading.
But I don't know, why can't
I have a reader on this one?
It has podcasts, it has music.
This single camera here,
it's a 50 megapixel sensor,
which bends down to 12,
and there are no settings
for shooting full 50 megapixel resolution,
or changing the resolution
to anything else at all,
or aspect ratio, or focal
length, just flash and exposure.
And I know the photos aren't good,
but if I do need to send them to someone,
this phone doesn't support RCS,
so I'd be sending them
in an ultra compressed,
not encrypted MMS message instead.
That also means all two-factor
authentication using this
would have to be done via insecure SMS,
because there's no authenticator
apps here, obviously.
And I also happen to have a bunch
of other conversations happening
in other messaging apps,
WhatsApp, Telegram, Discord, Slack.
I can't have any of
those conversations here.
And I also happen to use
Spotify for my music.
And so, I'm really not trying
to move all of those playlists
and all of those songs
manually to this app.
I would've liked some
kind of Spotify support
or something like that.
But hang on, I've realized
I'm asking for more here.
And that's because in order
to use this as my daily phone,
I mean, there are things
that I need it to do
that it isn't capable of.
Like, I use to-do list
apps and Google Drive
and weather apps on my phone
every day, so I need more,
but the more I ask for it to do,
the more I'm just going
back to turning it into
a regular smartphone again.
So, a really big part of the
review process for this phone
for me has been trying to figure out,
is this phone really
supposed to be your primary,
only smartphone that you carry?
Or, if we're being honest,
is it more just like you do have this
as like your main phone,
but you also carry like another smartphone
in your back pocket,
or you have a computer in your backpack
or something everywhere you go?
Because that's two very different ways
of looking at this product.
And maybe just because I
can't make this my main phone
doesn't mean other people couldn't.
Like, maybe this could be for a kid who,
this is their first smartphone
and their parents are
getting this for them
so that they can't also drown in TikToks,
or maybe a particularly
offline professional,
or just someone who prioritizes
minimizing distractions
at all costs.
Like, this could be fully functional,
technically, for those people.
So, just because it's not
for me doesn't mean it's bad.
Think of it like a bicycle.
Like, for some people,
that will be their primary
and only means of
transportation all the time,
but for a lot of other people,
it'll be more of a fun
weekend recreational cruiser.
At least that's what I would say
if there wasn't one
more overarching reason
why probably nobody should buy this phone.
(gentle electronic beep)
Look, this phone is nice.
It is built well, it
is satisfying to hold,
it's unique, and it's
for a niche audience,
but there's no way anybody
should pay $800 for this phone.
I'm sorry. There's just no way.
Now, if you pre-order, it's only $600,
which is a little less ridiculous,
but I still think it's too much.
This is my only real
problem with this phone,
just because conceptually,
you're getting a device that does less,
that's the whole point,
but paying more than a normal phone
for something like that
just seems ridiculous.
Like, I looked at the
spec sheet of this phone.
Obviously, it doesn't
have to have great specs
to do the limited things that it does,
but the specs are a
Snapdragon 4 Gen 2 Chip,
128 gigs of storage, six gigs of RAM,
the single camera, a four-inch 1080p OLED,
and an 1,800 milliampere-hour battery.
Like, that is not the spec
sheet of an $800 phone.
Just for some context,
some other phones using the
same chip are the Poco M6 Plus,
the Redmi 13, and the vivo Y39,
all of which retail for under $200.
And look, I know the specs
were never gonna be the reason
that this phone costs a lot.
In fact, if you wanna
know the real reason,
it's probably some
combination of the materials,
which is, you know, it's
metal, it's high quality,
but also software development costs,
'cause it's unique
software, and low volume,
so it's just gonna cost more
with economies of scale,
and also probably tariffs.
But there's actually a
really interesting video
that the Nothing Team did recently.
It's on their YouTube channel,
basically just pricing
out the rough cost behind
an imaginary smartphone.
It's really interesting.
I'll link a below if
you wanna check it out.
But understanding that a pretty niche,
low-volume phone like this
that's also made of all
metal and IP54 rated
and with a pretty massive front speaker
and a bunch of other kind
of oddly-shaped parts,
like, economies of scale says,
"Okay, it's not gonna be the
cheapest thing in the world,"
but it's just hard to get
all the way to six to $800
for a phone that does less on purpose,
like, when you could pay $500
and get a full-fledged smartphone
and then just put a minimal launcher on it
and then just delete the apps
that you don't wanna use,
you know what I mean?
Like, the Light Phone company
could have theoretically made
a launcher app instead of a phone,
but then they couldn't have
charged 800 bucks for it.
So I get that the point is on this phone,
you can't get trapped
doom scrolling on TikTok,
while on the regular
phone with a launcher,
you still could technically.
And it's a cool piece of hardware,
it's a really fun design
and I like that this stuff
is unique and that it exists,
but at the end of the day,
it's hard to get behind charging that much
for something that's
pretty much guaranteed
for most people going
to be their second phone
when they're already
carrying a full-priced,
fully capable phone probably
in their other pocket.
It kind of feels like
they're taking advantage
of people's lack of discipline
with this shiny new $800 box
that's gonna solve their
doom scrolling problem.
You know what is worth the money though?
The new Ridge Power Bank.
The value proposition
here is actually insane,
because yes, it is a power bank,
but it's really like a five-in-one,
all-in-one multi-tool type thing for $69.
Nice. Check it out at ridge.com/mkbhd
and see it for yourself.
And thanks to Ridge for
sponsoring this portion
of the video.
But I'll leave you with this.
This is your question of the video.
Do you honestly think
that you could daily drive
this as your only phone?
No backup, how long could you last?
Lemme know in the comments below.
Thanks for watching.
Catch you in the next one.
Peace.
(gentle music)
Related Songs