Display Bilingual:

[Music] 00:02
[Music] 00:24
in Rome, deep in the heart of the 00:27
Vatican. 00:29
They say there is an amazing object. It 00:30
becomes one of the real marvels of the 00:34
city and one of the chief things that a 00:36
pilgrim would go and see and venerate. 00:38
Not a painting or icon, but a true image 00:41
of Jesus Christ. It is called the veil 00:45
of Veronica. The Veronica was believed 00:49
to be a piece of fabric that touched the 00:52
face of Christ and then bore a 00:54
miraculous image. 00:57
Venerated for over a thousand years, 01:00
this was once the most prized relic in 01:02
Christrysendom and an object of 01:05
pilgrimage. But one man has a shocking 01:10
revelation. He believes the object in 01:13
the Vatican is a 01:15
fake. And he knows because he's found 01:18
the real one. 01:21
This is the story of Paul Batter's 01:23
journey of discovery to find what had 01:25
happened to the true face of God. 01:28
Confessing that this face has gone lost, 01:31
it was a hard thing to do. If he is 01:33
right, his discovery could have huge 01:36
implications for the history of the 01:39
church and for the future of 01:41
Christianity itself. It was the first 01:43
time for around 500 years that the pope 01:46
saw and 01:51
venerated the true face of 01:52
[Music] 02:01
Christ. The story began at a dinner in 02:02
Churin when journalist and author Paul 02:06
Bada met German art historian Professor 02:09
Hinrich Feifer. 02:12
[Music] 02:14
Father Feifer told Paul an amazing 02:17
tale that if true could rewrite history, 02:20
be the most significant discovery in 02:24
Christianity, and show how what was once 02:27
one of the most venerated objects in the 02:29
Vatican could be a fraud. I raised my 02:32
glass to 02:35
him. I thought he must have been crazy. 02:38
[Music] 02:42
The story revolved around a fabulous 02:49
relic, the veil of 02:52
Veronica, whose origins are immortalized 02:54
in most churches as the so-called sixth 02:57
station of the 03:00
cross. The stations of the cross take us 03:02
through Christ's last terrible journey 03:05
to his execution. 03:07
Every church has these images that we 03:10
call the stations of the cross. And that 03:12
allows us to accompany Jesus as he makes 03:13
his way from his condemnation to death 03:16
by Pontius Pilate right up to the moment 03:19
of crucifixion and his burial. 03:21
Step by step, the stations tell the tale 03:24
of the horrific suffering Jesus faced in 03:27
the leadup to his death. He was 03:30
scourged and crowned with 03:35
thorns before he carried the cross 03:41
through the narrow streets of 03:43
Jerusalem. Along the way, Jesus is met 03:47
by friends and supporters who share in 03:50
his pain and suffering. One of them was 03:53
said to be a woman known as Veronica. A 03:56
pious woman of Jerusalem saw Christ 04:00
suffering and bleeding and and sweating. 04:02
And she took her sweatcloth, which was a 04:05
cloth she was wearing around her head 04:10
and gave it to him to dry his face from 04:12
blood and sweat. 04:14
The legend has it that when Christ 04:16
handed the cloth back to her, 04:19
miraculously an image of his face had 04:21
transferred to the 04:25
material. But it is only a story. 04:31
Veronica herself is not actually 04:34
mentioned in the Bible. The legend of 04:37
Veronica is moving us because it is a 04:40
legend of compassion and love and a 04:43
miracle. 04:45
And it allows us to have an image of 04:46
Christ. 04:49
Whatever its actual origin, stories of a 04:51
cloth bearing a miraculous image of 04:54
Christ, not made by human hands, 04:56
continued to circulate throughout the 04:59
early Christian period. There's a whole 05:01
interconnected network of legends about 05:04
a miraculous image of Jesus's face which 05:08
seem to come from different sources and 05:11
have different motivations behind them. 05:14
[Music] 05:19
Somehow this miraculous cloth with its 05:24
image of Christ made its way to Rome. 05:27
The first documented evidence of the 05:31
Veronica being in Rome is from 705 when 05:33
Pope John II built a shrine for the 05:37
Veronica. 05:41
By 1200, the Veronica was on permanent 05:43
display in St. Peter's Basilica and 05:46
thousands of people flocked to see it. 05:49
This image became hugely important to 05:51
the world of art. Until then, artists 05:55
had no idea of what Jesus actually 06:00
looked like. There are no clues in the 06:02
Gospels. So, they depicted him in an 06:04
idealistic or general 06:07
way. There are images of Jesus in the 06:10
catacombs and elsewhere from the second 06:12
and third centuries where Jesus just 06:15
looks like a normal young Roman man, 06:17
clean shaven, a bit plump. You can only 06:21
identify him by the fact that he's 06:24
performing a miracle. And he's normally 06:25
doing it in the way that a Roman god 06:27
would do. So for example, he's curing 06:29
someone by touching them with a stick. 06:31
But when the Veronica appeared, all that 06:36
changed. Now artists and worshippers 06:38
could look at an actual image of a real 06:42
face. 06:45
It was very visual and especially in the 06:47
Middle Ages, the visual side of the 06:49
faith was was tremendously important. 06:51
Having this imprint of Christ's face was 06:54
almost as good as having a photograph. 06:57
You had an idea how God who became man 07:00
really looked. God was not an idea. It 07:03
was a face. God got a face, a human 07:07
face. 07:09
This same face was seen and copied by 07:12
many of the great artists and appeared 07:15
in more and more 07:17
works. It became the model for Jesus. 07:19
The characteristics are always the same. 07:23
The parted hair, the thin beard, the 07:26
nose and mouth. The Veronica was copied 07:29
widely and the simplified image of 07:32
Christ's face was distributed across the 07:35
world. 07:38
In fact, this image became so popular 07:40
that a whole guild of specialist artists 07:42
was created just to meet the demand. 07:45
from the middle of the 14th century get 07:49
really clear evidence for people who are 07:51
reproducing the Veronica and reproducing 07:54
the holy images of Rome and selling 07:56
those on as as copies but copies which 07:58
bear the same spiritual authority and 08:02
miracle working power that the original 08:05
did. The Veronica proved not only a 08:10
potent symbol but also a great source of 08:13
revenue as an object of pilgrimage. 08:16
The Veronica becomes a very important 08:20
relic in Rome that there's a chapel 08:23
dedicated to it in St. Peter's. It soon 08:25
becomes even the symbol of pilgrimage to 08:28
Rome. So it becomes one of the real 08:30
marvels of the city and one of the chief 08:32
things that a pilgrim would go and see 08:35
and venerate. 08:36
Successive popes used the Veronica to 08:39
increase their prestige and influence. 08:41
Innocent thei is particularly interested 08:44
in promoting the the Veronica in part to 08:46
promote the city of Rome itself and to 08:50
encourage the pilgrimage to Rome. 08:53
Pope Innocent III granted indulgences 08:57
for those who prayed before the 09:00
Veronica, gave it its own feast day and 09:02
even prominarded it around the 09:05
city. The highlight of the holy year was 09:08
the showing of the Veronica because this 09:12
was the encounter with Christ on earth 09:15
when we were still alive. 09:17
Eventually, the Veronica became big 09:24
business. Numbers visiting Rome became 09:27
so vast that the decision was made to 09:29
tear down the old basilica of St. 09:32
Peter's and rebuild it. 09:34
One of the ways in which popes of the 09:38
early Renaissance proclaimed their uh 09:40
authority and created their legacy was 09:43
through major building projects. And St. 09:46
Peters is a good example of a 09:48
Renaissance pope crafting his legacy 09:50
with a oversized building project. 09:52
Dominating the center of this 09:57
magnificent new basilica is the altar 09:58
which according to tradition was built 10:01
above the tomb of St. Peter. 10:04
And then around it they have these four 10:06
pillars where they place the relics 10:10
which were so popular in the middle 10:12
ages. The head of St. Andrew, the veil 10:13
of Veronica, the holy lance and also 10:16
part of the true cross and each of these 10:19
relics in a sense being a cornerstone, a 10:22
pillar of this new basilica of St. 10:24
Peter's, the heart of the 10:27
church. In other words, the Veronica had 10:30
become one of the great pillars of the 10:33
Catholic Church. But then Rome entered a 10:35
dark period of disruption and violence 10:38
and everything changed. 10:41
On the 6th of May 10:48
1527, Rome was looted and attacked 10:51
ironically by the troops of the Holy 10:55
Roman 10:57
Emperor. The suck of Rome was a 10:58
catastrophe for the Roman church. For a 11:01
thousand years, Rome was a safe place 11:04
where all the pilgrims and the kings and 11:08
the emperors who came to Rome left 11:11
important donations at St. Peter. 11:13
In an orgy of violence, 500 men were 11:17
slain in front of the altar and many of 11:20
the relics it had housed disappeared. 11:22
According to the contemporary reports, 11:25
the most important relics were given 11:28
away in a pup and drinking soldiers were 11:30
drying their mouth with a veil of 11:35
Veronica. In time, the dust settled and 11:46
the new St. Peter's Basilica was finally 11:50
completed and 11:53
consecrated. But by then, something had 11:55
obviously 11:58
changed. Although the Vatican still 12:00
claimed to have the Veronica safe, it 12:02
was no longer on public 12:05
display. And on the rare occasions when 12:07
it was shown, it seemed to look 12:09
different. 12:11
Suddenly, the Veronica was not a clear 12:13
shiny image anymore, but a dark cloth 12:15
with some traces of blood. 12:19
It led some to wonder if the original 12:21
face of God had been lost. So, the big 12:24
question is what happened to the 12:28
original Veronica, the beautiful 12:31
Veronica which was painted by the 12:33
painters in the middle ages. It 12:35
disappeared. And here we have the 12:37
discovery of Father 12:41
[Music] 12:44
Fifer. At the dinner in Turin, Father 12:49
Feifer outlined his theory to Paul 12:53
Batter that the real face of God was no 12:55
longer in the 12:59
Vatican. Paul was skeptical. He had been 13:01
warned of Feifer's fantastical claims 13:04
before, but Father Feifer went further, 13:07
claiming he knew where the real Veronica 13:10
was 13:12
now, 120 mi away in a small town called 13:14
Manipello. 13:18
He said, "Yes, there's something quite 13:20
unknown in a little remote hilltop in 13:23
the Yutzi Mountains." He said, "How come 13:26
that does the whole world doesn't know 13:29
of it?" He said, "Yeah, that's a 13:30
mystery." you know, he made it even more 13:32
mysterious and so I I it was just 13:34
completely completely unbelievable. 13:37
Paul dismissed the whole theory. I 13:40
thought it's a fine story and but that 13:44
was it. He wasn't even curious about it. 13:46
But this chance meeting would prove to 13:50
be a turning point in Paul's life. 13:53
[Music] 13:58
Some months later, whilst traveling with 14:05
his daughter down the Adriatic coast, 14:07
Paul found himself near 14:10
Manipello and the church that Father 14:12
Feifer had claimed was the home to the 14:15
real Veronica. Then we got there and I 14:18
thought it was about lunchtime, so maybe 14:21
we could have a little lunch up there 14:23
and have look at it. 14:25
The town of Manipello, nestled within 14:29
the mountainous region of Abrutzo, is in 14:31
a remote area off the beaten track and 14:33
largely forgotten by the outside world. 14:36
Got off the highway. Uh the restaurant 14:40
was closed and I got here to the church. 14:42
[Music] 14:48
Walking into the 14:55
church, Paul saw the image for the first 14:56
time. The church had a mass and after 15:00
the mass, I got up there and this image 15:03
was just I mean, he looked at me. 15:06
Paul was immediately struck by the eyes, 15:14
the gaze of Christ on this transparent 15:18
image. 15:22
Seeing somebody's face is really seeing 15:24
the person, you know, looking into 15:27
somebody's eyes, looking at their their 15:29
expression. We can learn so much about 15:31
that person. We believe that God became 15:33
man in Jesus Christ. Um, and to be able 15:36
to see that face as it existed in in his 15:39
humanity, it would be a wonderful link 15:41
with the divine nature. 15:44
[Music] 15:53
Paul noticed that the material was so 15:55
fine that in certain light the image 15:58
almost 16:03
[Music] 16:04
vanished only returning when illuminated 16:05
by a torch is constantly 16:08
exposed and you can walk nearby you can 16:11
walk around. You can take pictures from 16:15
any direction and you can see how the 16:17
light from the many windows in this 16:20
church go through 16:23
[Music] 16:26
it. You can put your hand behind it. You 16:28
can see your hand. You can put a 16:31
newspaper behind it and you can read the 16:33
newspapers because it is so thin and so 16:36
fine. And when you get very close to it, 16:38
you see that the image itself is 16:42
translucent. You don't see any color. 16:45
Paul could have gazed at the image 16:50
forever, but was pressed for time. My 16:53
daughter, she was very unpatient. Let's 16:57
let's get off. I'm hungry. Let's have 16:59
something to eat. So, she dragged me 17:01
away. But I had to look at it one more 17:04
time. 17:07
And then he looked at me as if somebody 17:10
who would just be awakening. 17:12
Deeply affected, but not sure of what 17:16
he'd just seen. Paul couldn't bring 17:19
himself to believe it was the real 17:22
thing. And after leaving, put it to one 17:24
side. 17:27
Two years passed and after working 17:36
abroad as the Jerusalem correspondent 17:38
for the German daily newspaper Devet, 17:40
Paul returned to 17:43
Rome. It was here that the Veronica 17:45
reappeared in his life once again. 17:48
saw around the corner I saw a little 17:52
poster announcing a not a press 17:55
conference a lecture of a certain 17:58
butterf what he's going to tell me about 18:05
the image 18:07
father Hinrich Fifer is a German Jesuit 18:10
scholar specializing in medieval 18:13
religious art 18:16
fatherifer is one of the leading art 18:18
historians of the Christian world, a 18:21
highly educated man and very important 18:24
art historian. 18:27
During the course of the lecture, Father 18:30
Feifer reiterated his claim that the 18:33
Manipello image is the veil of 18:35
Veronica. During the talk, Paul was 18:39
struck by the detail in the magnified 18:41
close-ups. 18:43
Seeing them brought a sudden 18:46
revelation. It was real and he believed 18:51
in it. 18:55
I thought this is it. It must be 18:57
everything must be true. But these 18:59
images there's no comparison to it. I 19:01
hadn't seen photos like this before. 19:03
He was so fascinating. But it became the 19:07
mission of his life to spread the 19:10
message of the human image of God around 19:13
the 19:17
world. Paul was desperate to tell the 19:26
world about these miraculous images and 19:29
write a book, but he knew how hard it 19:31
would be to convince people. 19:34
It was a formidable challenge. He would 19:40
need a lot of evidence to win over 19:43
skeptics. The first question is, how can 19:46
there even be a face displayed in 19:49
Manipello if there is already a veil of 19:51
Veronica in the 19:54
Vatican? Every year on Passion Sunday at 19:57
5:00 20:00
p.m., you can see what today is 20:02
venerated in St. Peter the Veronica 20:05
because the cannons of St. Peters appear 20:07
on the balcony and bless the faithful 20:10
with the modernday Veronica which is in 20:12
a in a huge heavy silver 20:15
frame but you can't see a human 20:19
[Music] 20:22
face. Drawing on all his Roman contacts, 20:27
he tried to secure a meeting with the 20:31
Vatican authorities. 20:32
Eventually in summer of 2004 after much 20:36
persistence he was granted an audience 20:40
with Professor Arnold Nestlerat. 20:42
He's a director of the Vatican museums. 20:46
He's a very prestigious position. He's a 20:48
highly respected person in the world of 20:52
a heart. 20:54
Keen to learn the Vatican's angle on the 20:59
Manipello image, Paul met with Professor 21:01
Nestlerat. He eagerly showed him 21:08
pictures of the Manipello 21:10
face and questioned the professor about 21:16
what it could be. 21:19
But professor Nestlerat would not be 21:24
drawn into the debate about the 21:27
manipello image. 21:28
He had heard something of it and he had 21:32
heard something of fifer and he was from 21:34
the big front who had decided about part 21:37
of fifer that he's not to be taken 21:39
serious. 21:41
Professor Nestlerat would neither lend 21:43
any credence to the manipello image nor 21:45
let Paul see the Vatican's Veronica. 21:48
When pressed to go and examine the image 21:53
in Manipello for himself, the professor 21:55
declined, claiming it was beyond his 21:58
jurisdiction. The official channels had 22:01
got him nowhere. He needed a different 22:04
approach for his investigation. 22:06
[Music] 22:09
If he can't see the Vatican's image, he 22:20
needed to find out more about the one in 22:23
Manipello. When had it arrived and how 22:25
had it got there? 22:28
The problem with something like the 22:31
image of Manipello is that there just 22:32
isn't a paper trail basically. So, we 22:34
know this object has been here in 22:36
Manipello for a certain amount of time. 22:38
We know that it arrived there under 22:40
certain circumstances, but before that, 22:42
who knows? Basically, there's just no 22:45
way of telling. 22:47
Paul realized that if it is real, then 22:49
the most likely time for its arrival in 22:52
Manipello would have been around 22:54
1527 during the sack of 22:57
Rome. And there seemed to be a link. 23:00
Paul's research showed that Pope Clement 23:04
took refuge in the castle Santangelo 23:07
after the sack of Rome. Something as 23:10
valuable as the Veronica wouldn't have 23:13
been left 23:15
behind. Whilst waiting for the looting 23:17
to end, Paul thought it possible that 23:19
the commander of the castle had it 23:21
spirited away to safety far from Rome. 23:24
Intriguingly, the commander had an 23:29
estate in 23:31
Manipello, but it all seemed to make 23:33
sense. One very realistic perspective is 23:36
what believes in the Castello Zangeli 23:40
um who had land in Manoello safeguarded 23:44
it and brought it there to protect it. 23:48
But 23:52
confusingly there is another version of 23:53
events. 23:56
In 23:57
1506 a stranger appeared in Manupello 23:58
and gave it to a local and this local 24:03
um wanted to ask questions but suddenly 24:07
the stranger disappeared and he believed 24:10
he was an 24:12
angel. This didn't add up as 1506 is 21 24:15
years before the sack of Rome. 24:19
Paul then looked at what was happening 24:22
in Rome during this period and 24:24
discovered very little was written about 24:27
the Veronica for a 100red years after 24:28
the sack of Rome until the consecration 24:30
of St. Peter's Basilica in 24:33
1626. Officially the Veronica was still 24:38
there housed within one of the four 24:42
famous pillars. 24:45
[Music] 24:47
But Paul discovered something puzzling. 24:50
In 1629, Pope Urban VI stopped the veil 24:52
being 24:56
displayed. The lucrative trade in copies 24:57
was prohibited and he demanded all 25:00
existing copies be destroyed on pain of 25:03
excommunication. It was as if someone 25:07
was trying to hide something. 25:09
[Music] 25:12
It was important to recall all the 25:14
images of the Veronica which has 25:18
disappeared and to wait until it 25:21
disappears from the memory of pilgrims 25:24
and Christian 25:28
faithful. Paul discovered that the story 25:31
of an angel bringing the image to 25:33
Manipello first appeared during the time 25:35
the images were being destroyed. 25:38
When the Manipello image was 25:44
scrutinized, 12 towns people came up 25:46
with the story that their face of God 25:49
was brought to them by an angel long 25:51
before the sack of Rome. To Paul, now 25:54
this story made sense. The villagers had 25:57
used this tale to pretend their image 26:00
couldn't possibly be of the real 26:02
Veronica, and by doing so had protected 26:05
their image from destruction. 26:08
It was to disguise something and then 26:12
they invented the story. I mean that an 26:15
angel has brought it here. What you can 26:17
do easily in Italy because Italy is full 26:19
of 26:22
saints. Miracles are not strange to to 26:22
Italians. Only after time had passed did 26:30
the Vatican start showing the Veronica 26:33
again. 26:36
But it seemed different and much darker. 26:38
Replacement was not a good or bad copy, 26:41
but something completely different. You 26:44
had to destroy the original images and 26:46
replace them by what you have. Later, 26:50
the Vatican gave out new prints of the 26:54
Veronica which resembled what they have 26:58
today. But this is a clear indication 27:01
that the original relic disappeared and 27:04
was exchanged. 27:06
The evidence for this can be found in 27:09
art. Now, not only did it look 27:14
completely different, so did the copies 27:17
made by 27:20
artists. It all seemed to suggest that 27:21
the original had been lost. 27:24
[Music] 27:29
Paul was now certain that the original 27:32
couldn't be in the Vatican and that at 27:35
some point the image was exchanged and a 27:38
new one put in its 27:40
place. But to prove that he needed more 27:42
evidence, he looked at early 27:47
descriptions of the 27:49
veil. In the past, it was recorded as 27:51
being almost transparent. Even the 27:54
Protestant reformer Martin Luther said 27:56
it was like a translucent piece of 27:59
linen. Unlike the blackened image in the 28:01
Vatican, the Manipello image fitted that 28:04
description. 28:08
There are many compelling reasons to 28:09
think that that might be the case. The 28:12
fact that the veil is transparent, that 28:14
we can see through it, and we knew that 28:17
was the case for the medieval Veronica. 28:18
[Music] 28:25
Paul's attempts to see the Vatican's 28:29
Veronica continued to be 28:32
rebuffed. Thinking laterally, he decided 28:35
to visit their vast treasury 28:38
[Music] 28:40
museum. He was looking for any evidence 28:44
that would tie the Manipello image to 28:47
Rome before 1527. 28:49
In the treasury of St. Peter's there is 28:53
a broken frame um in which the Veronica 28:55
was once kept a frame that you could 28:57
observe from both sides just like in 29:00
Manopel and roughly the same dimensions. 29:02
For Paul it was another clue. Only a 29:06
transparent image that could be viewed 29:09
from both sides would ever be displayed 29:11
in this way. To have a frame which is 29:13
translucent only makes sense if you have 29:17
a translucent 29:19
cloth like the veil of Manoello. The 29:21
dimensions 29:25
fit. And this is why we believe that the 29:26
original Veronica which was venerated in 29:30
this frame is what we today call the 29:33
wheel of Manopell. 29:37
If the true Veronica was still in the 29:39
Vatican, why had this frame been smashed 29:41
and the original cut away? Taken all the 29:44
information together which you have, 29:47
there's no doubt about it. It must have 29:49
been the sack of Rome. 29:51
[Music] 29:54
Paul concluded it was the Manipello 29:56
image that was torn from this smashed 29:59
frame. The image even has a glass chip 30:01
still embedded in it. 30:05
The whole story of his frame is giving 30:08
even more credence to the theory of 30:10
professor fif Paul that the true 30:14
veronical of the middle ages is a 30:17
manopello 30:18
today. It is a conflict about 30:21
plausibility. If somebody comes up with 30:25
the theory which is more plausible I'm 30:28
the first one to applaud it. the first 30:30
one. 30:32
For Paul, the evidence linking the 30:35
Manipello image to the original Veronica 30:38
was conclusive. He was certain that they 30:40
are one and the same. This now begged 30:43
the biggest question of all. Could this 30:46
really be the face of God? And if so, 30:49
how had it been created? 30:53
Paul went back to the original story and 31:03
looked for 31:05
clues. The problem is St. Veronica 31:07
doesn't exist in the Bible. One of the 31:10
striking features of the western version 31:13
of the legend is the character of 31:15
Veronica herself. A saint kind of 31:17
created by clerical error if you like. 31:19
The name obviously derives from the 31:21
Latin for the true icon or Latin and 31:23
Greek. the true image of Christ um 31:25
becomes the Vera Eone Veronica. You've 31:29
you've you know invented a saint. 31:32
In other words, there never was a 31:35
Veronica. Her name simply referred to 31:38
the cloth itself. 31:41
The legend of Veronica was only one of 31:43
many attempts to explain what we really 31:47
have. But the name is 31:50
revealing what we are talking about. 31:52
Vera Eonia the true image was not the 31:55
name of a woman but the name of the 32:00
[Music] 32:04
image. The implications of this are 32:06
enormous. 32:09
[Music] 32:11
If Veronica did not exist, then the 32:13
image could not have been created when 32:16
she had wiped Jesus's face on the way to 32:18
the 32:20
crucifixion. So, how did it get 32:22
[Music] 32:25
there? Paul examined the material itself 32:27
and discovered how extraordinarily fine 32:31
it was. 32:33
It didn't look like linen or even silk. 32:35
But what could it be? Researching on the 32:39
internet, he came across an ancient 32:43
fabric called bissus. 32:44
There are several types of bissels in um 32:50
antiquity, but the most precious one was 32:54
created from the silk of a a shell of a 32:57
muscle. It's called pinobilis. is a is a 33:01
very large Mediterranean muscle. 90 cm 33:05
large 33:09
thing. Divers harvested bisus by hand it 33:12
took thousands of threads to make the 33:15
smallest piece of silk and as a result 33:17
it was extremely 33:21
valuable. Bissus was so precious it had 33:23
long been revered as a religious 33:26
material. 33:28
Critically, it was used during the time 33:30
of Christ. 33:33
It was the most precious fabric in the 33:35
antique times. You find it in the graves 33:37
of the pharaohs in Egypt. You find it in 33:40
the cloth of the high priest. The effort 33:43
made of bus in the curtain of the 33:46
temple. Bus was mentioned. It's mostly 33:48
um translated in English. For instance, 33:52
shining linen. 33:54
But was the manipello image made of 33:57
[Music] 34:01
bissus? Continuing his research, Paul 34:05
tracked down a woman in Sardinia, the 34:08
last muscle silk 34:11
[Music] 34:13
cultivator. He flew her to Manipello to 34:16
see the image for herself. 34:18
[Music] 34:25
We brought here to the to the image of 34:29
the 34:31
veil. She got on her 34:35
knees. He said, "Oh, dear. Oh, 34:39
dear. That's 34:42
besus. That's m 34:45
[Music] 34:52
Bissus was far too valuable to have been 34:55
used as something to mop up 34:57
sweat. So, how might the image have got 35:00
there? Paul went back to the Bible to 35:03
look for clues. 35:06
After Jesus died, he was taken down from 35:18
the cross and laid in the tomb with the 35:20
different cloths needed for his 35:23
burial. A shroud to wrap the body and a 35:25
veil to cover his face. 35:29
Everybody was expecting to do the final 35:33
burial on Sunday morning. That's why the 35:36
women returned to to wash and clean and 35:38
unbalmed the body. 35:41
When they came, the body had 35:44
disappeared. The tomb was 35:47
empty. He was not there anymore because 35:50
he was not dead anymore. He had 35:54
risen. In John chapter 20, there's that 36:02
wonderful description of Peter and John 36:04
running to the empty tomb. and they've 36:07
just heard from the women that Jesus is 36:09
no longer in the tomb and they go and 36:12
investigate. The gospels are very clear 36:15
that when the disciples entered the 36:18
empty tomb, there were various burial 36:20
cloths lying around, not just the 36:23
shroud, but amongst others the cloth 36:25
that was around the face of 36:27
Christ. Such a funeral veil would have 36:29
been made of a fine valuable material 36:33
like 36:35
bissus. Could it have been that whilst 36:37
wrapped around Jesus's head, it had 36:40
miraculously taken on the image of his 36:42
face? 36:45
The church clearly believes in in the 36:47
supernatural. Um, it clearly believes in 36:49
the miraculous. It clearly believes that 36:51
the divine can work in the world. So, 36:54
it's certainly open to the possibility 36:56
of images made without human hands. 36:59
It was the image of of a Christ who is 37:05
alive rather than the image that we find 37:07
on the shroud of Chin, the image of a 37:10
dead 37:12
man. For the early Christians, it must 37:15
have been a 37:18
revelation. A 37:20
revelation. that not only the body of 37:22
the suffering Christ was imprinted on 37:26
the burial cloth, but we also have the 37:28
face of the resurrected Christ on a 37:32
[Music] 37:36
veil. And of course, both relics were 37:39
venerated and given from generation to 37:44
generation. 37:47
So, could the Manipello image have been 37:53
made by a miraculous 37:56
process? Skeptics have often claimed 38:03
that the Manipello image must just be a 38:06
painting. But Paul discovered Bissus has 38:09
an unusual quality. You cannot dye or 38:11
paint on it. 38:15
Paul verified it is indeed not ordinary 38:17
silk but shell silk which you cannot 38:21
paint. There are some very small 38:27
pigments by meeting evil painters who 38:30
try to refresh or to intensify colors in 38:32
some point or maybe even try to put fur 38:36
images against it to get the replica 38:39
blessed by the original. You call it 38:42
secondass relic or relic by touch. 38:44
But verified it is not a human 38:48
being. For Paul, all the pieces 38:55
supporting his belief in the truth 38:58
behind the manello image were fitting 39:00
into 39:02
place. From the Bible, he believed he 39:03
had deduced what the cloth itself was 39:07
used for. rather than being the cloth 39:09
used by that pious woman as as Jesus 39:12
carried the cross that it was actually 39:15
one of the burial cloths of our Lord. 39:17
From paintings he saw how the same image 39:21
had been revered in Rome throughout the 39:23
Middle Ages. 39:26
If you compare the Wto Santo of 39:28
Mano with all the paintings we have 39:31
after Veronica and Rome, they are 39:35
identical. They're identical. even in 39:38
details. 39:41
And from the broken frame, he could see 39:43
how it had been saved after the sacking 39:45
of Rome and sent to Manipello, where it 39:47
had been quietly forgotten for nearly 39:50
500 years. It's so evident. This is the 39:52
veil. There's no doubt about I mean, you 39:57
could rip my skin off. I mean this is 40:00
it for Paul Batterder. The story of 40:08
Manipello's face of God was almost 40:11
complete and he could start writing up 40:14
his 40:16
theory. After completing his research, 40:18
he sent all his evidence along with 40:21
photographs to Pope John Paul 40:23
II. It had been an incredible journey. I 40:26
couldn't I couldn't believe it. But but 40:31
this the whole the whole story every 40:33
time and again I had to pinch myself 40:35
because it was so a miraculous 40:38
story. Paul's work found a wide 40:42
audience. Not only was it seen by Pope 40:45
John Paul but also by Cardinal Ratzinger 40:47
the leading authority on Catholic 40:51
doctrine and thought who complimented 40:53
Paul on his work. 40:55
And then out of the blue on Sunday the 41:08
13th of March 41:11
2005, Paul Bada was granted an 41:13
extraordinary 41:17
opportunity to see the version of the 41:20
Veronica in the Vatican. 41:23
Making his way into St. Peters, he was 41:27
aware that this could be the final piece 41:29
of the puzzle. 41:32
I've been I don't know how come that I 41:34
have seen it that I all of a sudden the 41:36
doors open. I could enter the the 41:39
column. 41:40
Within the Veronica column is a 41:42
staircase leading to a small chapel 41:44
housing the actual image 41:47
itself. 41:50
Of course, Paul Bad has seen what they 41:52
believe to be the Veronica in the 41:56
Vatican right now and had the 41:57
opportunity to see the Israelic from 42:00
close by. 42:02
In the depths of the Veronica column, he 42:04
finally saw the veil of 42:07
Veronica. But it was a dark, 42:10
unrecognizable image, nothing like the 42:12
old artist's 42:15
reproductions. And it was housed in a 42:16
heavy, ornate picture frame. 42:19
Clearly this was a completely different 42:23
image. 42:26
What I saw there I saw big silver frame. 42:27
You see this hoax as might call it or 42:31
copy. Everything had disappeared. 42:34
He was even denied permission to 42:38
photograph it. The Vatican have taken 42:40
their own 42:43
photos but they are rarely shown. 42:44
The reason why they don't publish this 42:47
pictures is they don't want to 42:49
disappoint the faithful by revealing 42:51
that there's no face on the Veronica 42:53
anymore. To this day, no pope has openly 42:59
admitted that the Vatican Veronica ever 43:03
disappeared or that the barely visible 43:05
face shown today is anything other than 43:08
what had always been on display. 43:10
But Paul had no doubt about what had 43:14
really happened. 43:16
It was a trick. It was a trick from the 43:18
500 years ago, from these times of 43:21
Makaveli. Paul is certain that this 43:24
trick or hoax was deliberately 43:26
perpetrated to maintain the illusion 43:29
that the Vatican still had the real 43:31
one. But if this had happened hundreds 43:36
of years ago, why not admit it now? I 43:39
think there's no question that having 43:42
the Veronica in your church if you 43:43
happen to be the pope would be an 43:46
incredibly uh useful asset. You know, 43:48
it's an item with incredible holiness 43:51
and power. Everyone is is aruck by it. 43:53
Um you're going to get a lot of people 43:57
coming to see it and it shores up your 43:58
power effectively as leader of the 44:01
church. confessing that this face has 44:04
gone lost. It was a hard thing to do 44:06
for Rome and her powerful popes. Such a 44:09
monumental loss of face would have been 44:12
deeply 44:15
embarrassing. It's a catastrophe for the 44:16
church of Rome. He lost the faith of 44:19
God. Not the faith in God, but the faith 44:22
of God. 44:24
Paul thought there may have been another 44:27
reason why the hoax was perpetrated. The 44:29
Veronica had earned the church a lot of 44:31
money. They did not come to see St. 44:34
Peter. They did not even come to see the 44:37
pope as they do today. They wanted to 44:40
see the veil. 44:42
Pilgrims had to be shown something. And 44:44
that's just what 44:47
happened. What started as a small hoax 44:49
was simply allowed to continue until it 44:52
became widely believed. 44:54
It's easy to dismiss it as just a 44:57
cynical cashing in exercise. And I'm 44:59
sure it was partly a cynical cashing in 45:01
exercise, but it was also a way of 45:03
making that pilgrimage real. I mean, 45:06
remember the whole idea of pilgrimage, 45:08
at least in theory, is to take part in 45:10
the physicality of something holy. 45:14
But others are more sympathetic about 45:20
why the Veronica might have been 45:22
replaced. 45:24
First of all, I have to disagree with 45:26
both Father Fifer and my dear friend 45:30
Paul B in the idea that the canons of 45:32
St. Peter perpetrated a hoax, a pious 45:35
forgery, a pious fraud. I do not believe 45:39
it. I believe they were hysterically 45:42
searching for something and just took 45:46
the second best and believed it because 45:49
they wanted to believe it. But visits 45:51
the right Veronica. 45:54
On April the 2nd, 45:56
2005, Pope John Paul II died. He was 45:58
succeeded by the man who had 46:02
complimented Paul on his book, Cardinal 46:04
Ratzinger, who became Pope Benedict I 46:07
16th. 46:10
On the 1st of September 2006, Pope 46:18
Benedict visited 46:21
Manipello. Often he visited Italian 46:23
shrines to to venerate the relics or or 46:25
the local traditions. 46:28
[Music] 46:32
And there's that very evocative image of 46:40
Pope Benedict just staring at at the 46:44
veil in Manopella. There's a real sense 46:46
of an encounter of a of a encountering 46:48
face to face um with Christ. He was 46:51
clearly very moved. For Paul this was 46:53
the justification for all his hard work 46:57
when he came to Monella for the first 47:01
pope. Then he prayed here in silence 47:03
about uh he bent his knee in front of it 47:07
and then for more than 8 minutes he's 47:11
been in sil prayer in front of it. I 47:13
mean it was very very 47:16
moving. It was the first 47:19
time for we believe around 500 years 47:21
that the pope saw and venerated the true 47:26
face of Christ of the resurrected 47:29
Christ. 47:31
Pope Benedict's visit changed 47:35
everything. 47:37
A week later on St. Peter Square in the 47:40
next audience he said if we want to know 47:43
who God is then we only have to look 47:46
into the face of his son and there we 47:49
see who God is and how God is. Although 47:51
not actually authenticating the image, 47:55
Pope Benedict's personal visit gave 47:58
credibility to those that believed this 48:00
was the true face of 48:03
God. He brought the image back into the 48:05
world. That's what he did. 48:09
Paul and many of the faithful believe 48:12
there is no doubting that this image is 48:14
genuine. But there will always be 48:17
skeptics. They want proper scientific 48:20
evidence to show how the image got there 48:23
and how old it is. The Guardians at 48:25
Manipello aren't against testing as long 48:28
as it is non-invasive and so doesn't 48:32
damage the 48:34
veil. They hope science will develop in 48:35
the future, allowing for a more detailed 48:38
examination, which they are sure will 48:41
vindicate their claims. 48:43
If this happens, then the veil of 48:46
Veronica would become one of the most 48:48
significant discoveries in Christian 48:50
history. Just as the Veronica was a very 48:53
popular relic in the Middle Ages, we're 48:56
now entering a new period, a revival of 48:58
this interest in in the holy face, 49:01
searching for the face of God, searching 49:03
for that personal encounter with him. 49:05
St. Paul wrote in his letters, if Christ 49:08
did not 49:11
resurrect, our faith is 49:12
worthless. So the 49:16
veneration of the Walto Santo is 49:19
concentrating the attention of 49:23
Christianity back onto the image of the 49:26
resurrected 49:30
Christ. And that's important. 49:32
[Music] 49:38
[Music] 50:04

– English Lyrics

📚 Don’t just sing along to "" – train your ears, learn vocab, and become a language pro in the app!
By
Viewed
43,106
Language
Learn this song

Lyrics & Translation

[English]
[Music]
[Music]
in Rome, deep in the heart of the
Vatican.
They say there is an amazing object. It
becomes one of the real marvels of the
city and one of the chief things that a
pilgrim would go and see and venerate.
Not a painting or icon, but a true image
of Jesus Christ. It is called the veil
of Veronica. The Veronica was believed
to be a piece of fabric that touched the
face of Christ and then bore a
miraculous image.
Venerated for over a thousand years,
this was once the most prized relic in
Christrysendom and an object of
pilgrimage. But one man has a shocking
revelation. He believes the object in
the Vatican is a
fake. And he knows because he's found
the real one.
This is the story of Paul Batter's
journey of discovery to find what had
happened to the true face of God.
Confessing that this face has gone lost,
it was a hard thing to do. If he is
right, his discovery could have huge
implications for the history of the
church and for the future of
Christianity itself. It was the first
time for around 500 years that the pope
saw and
venerated the true face of
[Music]
Christ. The story began at a dinner in
Churin when journalist and author Paul
Bada met German art historian Professor
Hinrich Feifer.
[Music]
Father Feifer told Paul an amazing
tale that if true could rewrite history,
be the most significant discovery in
Christianity, and show how what was once
one of the most venerated objects in the
Vatican could be a fraud. I raised my
glass to
him. I thought he must have been crazy.
[Music]
The story revolved around a fabulous
relic, the veil of
Veronica, whose origins are immortalized
in most churches as the so-called sixth
station of the
cross. The stations of the cross take us
through Christ's last terrible journey
to his execution.
Every church has these images that we
call the stations of the cross. And that
allows us to accompany Jesus as he makes
his way from his condemnation to death
by Pontius Pilate right up to the moment
of crucifixion and his burial.
Step by step, the stations tell the tale
of the horrific suffering Jesus faced in
the leadup to his death. He was
scourged and crowned with
thorns before he carried the cross
through the narrow streets of
Jerusalem. Along the way, Jesus is met
by friends and supporters who share in
his pain and suffering. One of them was
said to be a woman known as Veronica. A
pious woman of Jerusalem saw Christ
suffering and bleeding and and sweating.
And she took her sweatcloth, which was a
cloth she was wearing around her head
and gave it to him to dry his face from
blood and sweat.
The legend has it that when Christ
handed the cloth back to her,
miraculously an image of his face had
transferred to the
material. But it is only a story.
Veronica herself is not actually
mentioned in the Bible. The legend of
Veronica is moving us because it is a
legend of compassion and love and a
miracle.
And it allows us to have an image of
Christ.
Whatever its actual origin, stories of a
cloth bearing a miraculous image of
Christ, not made by human hands,
continued to circulate throughout the
early Christian period. There's a whole
interconnected network of legends about
a miraculous image of Jesus's face which
seem to come from different sources and
have different motivations behind them.
[Music]
Somehow this miraculous cloth with its
image of Christ made its way to Rome.
The first documented evidence of the
Veronica being in Rome is from 705 when
Pope John II built a shrine for the
Veronica.
By 1200, the Veronica was on permanent
display in St. Peter's Basilica and
thousands of people flocked to see it.
This image became hugely important to
the world of art. Until then, artists
had no idea of what Jesus actually
looked like. There are no clues in the
Gospels. So, they depicted him in an
idealistic or general
way. There are images of Jesus in the
catacombs and elsewhere from the second
and third centuries where Jesus just
looks like a normal young Roman man,
clean shaven, a bit plump. You can only
identify him by the fact that he's
performing a miracle. And he's normally
doing it in the way that a Roman god
would do. So for example, he's curing
someone by touching them with a stick.
But when the Veronica appeared, all that
changed. Now artists and worshippers
could look at an actual image of a real
face.
It was very visual and especially in the
Middle Ages, the visual side of the
faith was was tremendously important.
Having this imprint of Christ's face was
almost as good as having a photograph.
You had an idea how God who became man
really looked. God was not an idea. It
was a face. God got a face, a human
face.
This same face was seen and copied by
many of the great artists and appeared
in more and more
works. It became the model for Jesus.
The characteristics are always the same.
The parted hair, the thin beard, the
nose and mouth. The Veronica was copied
widely and the simplified image of
Christ's face was distributed across the
world.
In fact, this image became so popular
that a whole guild of specialist artists
was created just to meet the demand.
from the middle of the 14th century get
really clear evidence for people who are
reproducing the Veronica and reproducing
the holy images of Rome and selling
those on as as copies but copies which
bear the same spiritual authority and
miracle working power that the original
did. The Veronica proved not only a
potent symbol but also a great source of
revenue as an object of pilgrimage.
The Veronica becomes a very important
relic in Rome that there's a chapel
dedicated to it in St. Peter's. It soon
becomes even the symbol of pilgrimage to
Rome. So it becomes one of the real
marvels of the city and one of the chief
things that a pilgrim would go and see
and venerate.
Successive popes used the Veronica to
increase their prestige and influence.
Innocent thei is particularly interested
in promoting the the Veronica in part to
promote the city of Rome itself and to
encourage the pilgrimage to Rome.
Pope Innocent III granted indulgences
for those who prayed before the
Veronica, gave it its own feast day and
even prominarded it around the
city. The highlight of the holy year was
the showing of the Veronica because this
was the encounter with Christ on earth
when we were still alive.
Eventually, the Veronica became big
business. Numbers visiting Rome became
so vast that the decision was made to
tear down the old basilica of St.
Peter's and rebuild it.
One of the ways in which popes of the
early Renaissance proclaimed their uh
authority and created their legacy was
through major building projects. And St.
Peters is a good example of a
Renaissance pope crafting his legacy
with a oversized building project.
Dominating the center of this
magnificent new basilica is the altar
which according to tradition was built
above the tomb of St. Peter.
And then around it they have these four
pillars where they place the relics
which were so popular in the middle
ages. The head of St. Andrew, the veil
of Veronica, the holy lance and also
part of the true cross and each of these
relics in a sense being a cornerstone, a
pillar of this new basilica of St.
Peter's, the heart of the
church. In other words, the Veronica had
become one of the great pillars of the
Catholic Church. But then Rome entered a
dark period of disruption and violence
and everything changed.
On the 6th of May
1527, Rome was looted and attacked
ironically by the troops of the Holy
Roman
Emperor. The suck of Rome was a
catastrophe for the Roman church. For a
thousand years, Rome was a safe place
where all the pilgrims and the kings and
the emperors who came to Rome left
important donations at St. Peter.
In an orgy of violence, 500 men were
slain in front of the altar and many of
the relics it had housed disappeared.
According to the contemporary reports,
the most important relics were given
away in a pup and drinking soldiers were
drying their mouth with a veil of
Veronica. In time, the dust settled and
the new St. Peter's Basilica was finally
completed and
consecrated. But by then, something had
obviously
changed. Although the Vatican still
claimed to have the Veronica safe, it
was no longer on public
display. And on the rare occasions when
it was shown, it seemed to look
different.
Suddenly, the Veronica was not a clear
shiny image anymore, but a dark cloth
with some traces of blood.
It led some to wonder if the original
face of God had been lost. So, the big
question is what happened to the
original Veronica, the beautiful
Veronica which was painted by the
painters in the middle ages. It
disappeared. And here we have the
discovery of Father
[Music]
Fifer. At the dinner in Turin, Father
Feifer outlined his theory to Paul
Batter that the real face of God was no
longer in the
Vatican. Paul was skeptical. He had been
warned of Feifer's fantastical claims
before, but Father Feifer went further,
claiming he knew where the real Veronica
was
now, 120 mi away in a small town called
Manipello.
He said, "Yes, there's something quite
unknown in a little remote hilltop in
the Yutzi Mountains." He said, "How come
that does the whole world doesn't know
of it?" He said, "Yeah, that's a
mystery." you know, he made it even more
mysterious and so I I it was just
completely completely unbelievable.
Paul dismissed the whole theory. I
thought it's a fine story and but that
was it. He wasn't even curious about it.
But this chance meeting would prove to
be a turning point in Paul's life.
[Music]
Some months later, whilst traveling with
his daughter down the Adriatic coast,
Paul found himself near
Manipello and the church that Father
Feifer had claimed was the home to the
real Veronica. Then we got there and I
thought it was about lunchtime, so maybe
we could have a little lunch up there
and have look at it.
The town of Manipello, nestled within
the mountainous region of Abrutzo, is in
a remote area off the beaten track and
largely forgotten by the outside world.
Got off the highway. Uh the restaurant
was closed and I got here to the church.
[Music]
Walking into the
church, Paul saw the image for the first
time. The church had a mass and after
the mass, I got up there and this image
was just I mean, he looked at me.
Paul was immediately struck by the eyes,
the gaze of Christ on this transparent
image.
Seeing somebody's face is really seeing
the person, you know, looking into
somebody's eyes, looking at their their
expression. We can learn so much about
that person. We believe that God became
man in Jesus Christ. Um, and to be able
to see that face as it existed in in his
humanity, it would be a wonderful link
with the divine nature.
[Music]
Paul noticed that the material was so
fine that in certain light the image
almost
[Music]
vanished only returning when illuminated
by a torch is constantly
exposed and you can walk nearby you can
walk around. You can take pictures from
any direction and you can see how the
light from the many windows in this
church go through
[Music]
it. You can put your hand behind it. You
can see your hand. You can put a
newspaper behind it and you can read the
newspapers because it is so thin and so
fine. And when you get very close to it,
you see that the image itself is
translucent. You don't see any color.
Paul could have gazed at the image
forever, but was pressed for time. My
daughter, she was very unpatient. Let's
let's get off. I'm hungry. Let's have
something to eat. So, she dragged me
away. But I had to look at it one more
time.
And then he looked at me as if somebody
who would just be awakening.
Deeply affected, but not sure of what
he'd just seen. Paul couldn't bring
himself to believe it was the real
thing. And after leaving, put it to one
side.
Two years passed and after working
abroad as the Jerusalem correspondent
for the German daily newspaper Devet,
Paul returned to
Rome. It was here that the Veronica
reappeared in his life once again.
saw around the corner I saw a little
poster announcing a not a press
conference a lecture of a certain
butterf what he's going to tell me about
the image
father Hinrich Fifer is a German Jesuit
scholar specializing in medieval
religious art
fatherifer is one of the leading art
historians of the Christian world, a
highly educated man and very important
art historian.
During the course of the lecture, Father
Feifer reiterated his claim that the
Manipello image is the veil of
Veronica. During the talk, Paul was
struck by the detail in the magnified
close-ups.
Seeing them brought a sudden
revelation. It was real and he believed
in it.
I thought this is it. It must be
everything must be true. But these
images there's no comparison to it. I
hadn't seen photos like this before.
He was so fascinating. But it became the
mission of his life to spread the
message of the human image of God around
the
world. Paul was desperate to tell the
world about these miraculous images and
write a book, but he knew how hard it
would be to convince people.
It was a formidable challenge. He would
need a lot of evidence to win over
skeptics. The first question is, how can
there even be a face displayed in
Manipello if there is already a veil of
Veronica in the
Vatican? Every year on Passion Sunday at
5:00
p.m., you can see what today is
venerated in St. Peter the Veronica
because the cannons of St. Peters appear
on the balcony and bless the faithful
with the modernday Veronica which is in
a in a huge heavy silver
frame but you can't see a human
[Music]
face. Drawing on all his Roman contacts,
he tried to secure a meeting with the
Vatican authorities.
Eventually in summer of 2004 after much
persistence he was granted an audience
with Professor Arnold Nestlerat.
He's a director of the Vatican museums.
He's a very prestigious position. He's a
highly respected person in the world of
a heart.
Keen to learn the Vatican's angle on the
Manipello image, Paul met with Professor
Nestlerat. He eagerly showed him
pictures of the Manipello
face and questioned the professor about
what it could be.
But professor Nestlerat would not be
drawn into the debate about the
manipello image.
He had heard something of it and he had
heard something of fifer and he was from
the big front who had decided about part
of fifer that he's not to be taken
serious.
Professor Nestlerat would neither lend
any credence to the manipello image nor
let Paul see the Vatican's Veronica.
When pressed to go and examine the image
in Manipello for himself, the professor
declined, claiming it was beyond his
jurisdiction. The official channels had
got him nowhere. He needed a different
approach for his investigation.
[Music]
If he can't see the Vatican's image, he
needed to find out more about the one in
Manipello. When had it arrived and how
had it got there?
The problem with something like the
image of Manipello is that there just
isn't a paper trail basically. So, we
know this object has been here in
Manipello for a certain amount of time.
We know that it arrived there under
certain circumstances, but before that,
who knows? Basically, there's just no
way of telling.
Paul realized that if it is real, then
the most likely time for its arrival in
Manipello would have been around
1527 during the sack of
Rome. And there seemed to be a link.
Paul's research showed that Pope Clement
took refuge in the castle Santangelo
after the sack of Rome. Something as
valuable as the Veronica wouldn't have
been left
behind. Whilst waiting for the looting
to end, Paul thought it possible that
the commander of the castle had it
spirited away to safety far from Rome.
Intriguingly, the commander had an
estate in
Manipello, but it all seemed to make
sense. One very realistic perspective is
what believes in the Castello Zangeli
um who had land in Manoello safeguarded
it and brought it there to protect it.
But
confusingly there is another version of
events.
In
1506 a stranger appeared in Manupello
and gave it to a local and this local
um wanted to ask questions but suddenly
the stranger disappeared and he believed
he was an
angel. This didn't add up as 1506 is 21
years before the sack of Rome.
Paul then looked at what was happening
in Rome during this period and
discovered very little was written about
the Veronica for a 100red years after
the sack of Rome until the consecration
of St. Peter's Basilica in
1626. Officially the Veronica was still
there housed within one of the four
famous pillars.
[Music]
But Paul discovered something puzzling.
In 1629, Pope Urban VI stopped the veil
being
displayed. The lucrative trade in copies
was prohibited and he demanded all
existing copies be destroyed on pain of
excommunication. It was as if someone
was trying to hide something.
[Music]
It was important to recall all the
images of the Veronica which has
disappeared and to wait until it
disappears from the memory of pilgrims
and Christian
faithful. Paul discovered that the story
of an angel bringing the image to
Manipello first appeared during the time
the images were being destroyed.
When the Manipello image was
scrutinized, 12 towns people came up
with the story that their face of God
was brought to them by an angel long
before the sack of Rome. To Paul, now
this story made sense. The villagers had
used this tale to pretend their image
couldn't possibly be of the real
Veronica, and by doing so had protected
their image from destruction.
It was to disguise something and then
they invented the story. I mean that an
angel has brought it here. What you can
do easily in Italy because Italy is full
of
saints. Miracles are not strange to to
Italians. Only after time had passed did
the Vatican start showing the Veronica
again.
But it seemed different and much darker.
Replacement was not a good or bad copy,
but something completely different. You
had to destroy the original images and
replace them by what you have. Later,
the Vatican gave out new prints of the
Veronica which resembled what they have
today. But this is a clear indication
that the original relic disappeared and
was exchanged.
The evidence for this can be found in
art. Now, not only did it look
completely different, so did the copies
made by
artists. It all seemed to suggest that
the original had been lost.
[Music]
Paul was now certain that the original
couldn't be in the Vatican and that at
some point the image was exchanged and a
new one put in its
place. But to prove that he needed more
evidence, he looked at early
descriptions of the
veil. In the past, it was recorded as
being almost transparent. Even the
Protestant reformer Martin Luther said
it was like a translucent piece of
linen. Unlike the blackened image in the
Vatican, the Manipello image fitted that
description.
There are many compelling reasons to
think that that might be the case. The
fact that the veil is transparent, that
we can see through it, and we knew that
was the case for the medieval Veronica.
[Music]
Paul's attempts to see the Vatican's
Veronica continued to be
rebuffed. Thinking laterally, he decided
to visit their vast treasury
[Music]
museum. He was looking for any evidence
that would tie the Manipello image to
Rome before 1527.
In the treasury of St. Peter's there is
a broken frame um in which the Veronica
was once kept a frame that you could
observe from both sides just like in
Manopel and roughly the same dimensions.
For Paul it was another clue. Only a
transparent image that could be viewed
from both sides would ever be displayed
in this way. To have a frame which is
translucent only makes sense if you have
a translucent
cloth like the veil of Manoello. The
dimensions
fit. And this is why we believe that the
original Veronica which was venerated in
this frame is what we today call the
wheel of Manopell.
If the true Veronica was still in the
Vatican, why had this frame been smashed
and the original cut away? Taken all the
information together which you have,
there's no doubt about it. It must have
been the sack of Rome.
[Music]
Paul concluded it was the Manipello
image that was torn from this smashed
frame. The image even has a glass chip
still embedded in it.
The whole story of his frame is giving
even more credence to the theory of
professor fif Paul that the true
veronical of the middle ages is a
manopello
today. It is a conflict about
plausibility. If somebody comes up with
the theory which is more plausible I'm
the first one to applaud it. the first
one.
For Paul, the evidence linking the
Manipello image to the original Veronica
was conclusive. He was certain that they
are one and the same. This now begged
the biggest question of all. Could this
really be the face of God? And if so,
how had it been created?
Paul went back to the original story and
looked for
clues. The problem is St. Veronica
doesn't exist in the Bible. One of the
striking features of the western version
of the legend is the character of
Veronica herself. A saint kind of
created by clerical error if you like.
The name obviously derives from the
Latin for the true icon or Latin and
Greek. the true image of Christ um
becomes the Vera Eone Veronica. You've
you've you know invented a saint.
In other words, there never was a
Veronica. Her name simply referred to
the cloth itself.
The legend of Veronica was only one of
many attempts to explain what we really
have. But the name is
revealing what we are talking about.
Vera Eonia the true image was not the
name of a woman but the name of the
[Music]
image. The implications of this are
enormous.
[Music]
If Veronica did not exist, then the
image could not have been created when
she had wiped Jesus's face on the way to
the
crucifixion. So, how did it get
[Music]
there? Paul examined the material itself
and discovered how extraordinarily fine
it was.
It didn't look like linen or even silk.
But what could it be? Researching on the
internet, he came across an ancient
fabric called bissus.
There are several types of bissels in um
antiquity, but the most precious one was
created from the silk of a a shell of a
muscle. It's called pinobilis. is a is a
very large Mediterranean muscle. 90 cm
large
thing. Divers harvested bisus by hand it
took thousands of threads to make the
smallest piece of silk and as a result
it was extremely
valuable. Bissus was so precious it had
long been revered as a religious
material.
Critically, it was used during the time
of Christ.
It was the most precious fabric in the
antique times. You find it in the graves
of the pharaohs in Egypt. You find it in
the cloth of the high priest. The effort
made of bus in the curtain of the
temple. Bus was mentioned. It's mostly
um translated in English. For instance,
shining linen.
But was the manipello image made of
[Music]
bissus? Continuing his research, Paul
tracked down a woman in Sardinia, the
last muscle silk
[Music]
cultivator. He flew her to Manipello to
see the image for herself.
[Music]
We brought here to the to the image of
the
veil. She got on her
knees. He said, "Oh, dear. Oh,
dear. That's
besus. That's m
[Music]
Bissus was far too valuable to have been
used as something to mop up
sweat. So, how might the image have got
there? Paul went back to the Bible to
look for clues.
After Jesus died, he was taken down from
the cross and laid in the tomb with the
different cloths needed for his
burial. A shroud to wrap the body and a
veil to cover his face.
Everybody was expecting to do the final
burial on Sunday morning. That's why the
women returned to to wash and clean and
unbalmed the body.
When they came, the body had
disappeared. The tomb was
empty. He was not there anymore because
he was not dead anymore. He had
risen. In John chapter 20, there's that
wonderful description of Peter and John
running to the empty tomb. and they've
just heard from the women that Jesus is
no longer in the tomb and they go and
investigate. The gospels are very clear
that when the disciples entered the
empty tomb, there were various burial
cloths lying around, not just the
shroud, but amongst others the cloth
that was around the face of
Christ. Such a funeral veil would have
been made of a fine valuable material
like
bissus. Could it have been that whilst
wrapped around Jesus's head, it had
miraculously taken on the image of his
face?
The church clearly believes in in the
supernatural. Um, it clearly believes in
the miraculous. It clearly believes that
the divine can work in the world. So,
it's certainly open to the possibility
of images made without human hands.
It was the image of of a Christ who is
alive rather than the image that we find
on the shroud of Chin, the image of a
dead
man. For the early Christians, it must
have been a
revelation. A
revelation. that not only the body of
the suffering Christ was imprinted on
the burial cloth, but we also have the
face of the resurrected Christ on a
[Music]
veil. And of course, both relics were
venerated and given from generation to
generation.
So, could the Manipello image have been
made by a miraculous
process? Skeptics have often claimed
that the Manipello image must just be a
painting. But Paul discovered Bissus has
an unusual quality. You cannot dye or
paint on it.
Paul verified it is indeed not ordinary
silk but shell silk which you cannot
paint. There are some very small
pigments by meeting evil painters who
try to refresh or to intensify colors in
some point or maybe even try to put fur
images against it to get the replica
blessed by the original. You call it
secondass relic or relic by touch.
But verified it is not a human
being. For Paul, all the pieces
supporting his belief in the truth
behind the manello image were fitting
into
place. From the Bible, he believed he
had deduced what the cloth itself was
used for. rather than being the cloth
used by that pious woman as as Jesus
carried the cross that it was actually
one of the burial cloths of our Lord.
From paintings he saw how the same image
had been revered in Rome throughout the
Middle Ages.
If you compare the Wto Santo of
Mano with all the paintings we have
after Veronica and Rome, they are
identical. They're identical. even in
details.
And from the broken frame, he could see
how it had been saved after the sacking
of Rome and sent to Manipello, where it
had been quietly forgotten for nearly
500 years. It's so evident. This is the
veil. There's no doubt about I mean, you
could rip my skin off. I mean this is
it for Paul Batterder. The story of
Manipello's face of God was almost
complete and he could start writing up
his
theory. After completing his research,
he sent all his evidence along with
photographs to Pope John Paul
II. It had been an incredible journey. I
couldn't I couldn't believe it. But but
this the whole the whole story every
time and again I had to pinch myself
because it was so a miraculous
story. Paul's work found a wide
audience. Not only was it seen by Pope
John Paul but also by Cardinal Ratzinger
the leading authority on Catholic
doctrine and thought who complimented
Paul on his work.
And then out of the blue on Sunday the
13th of March
2005, Paul Bada was granted an
extraordinary
opportunity to see the version of the
Veronica in the Vatican.
Making his way into St. Peters, he was
aware that this could be the final piece
of the puzzle.
I've been I don't know how come that I
have seen it that I all of a sudden the
doors open. I could enter the the
column.
Within the Veronica column is a
staircase leading to a small chapel
housing the actual image
itself.
Of course, Paul Bad has seen what they
believe to be the Veronica in the
Vatican right now and had the
opportunity to see the Israelic from
close by.
In the depths of the Veronica column, he
finally saw the veil of
Veronica. But it was a dark,
unrecognizable image, nothing like the
old artist's
reproductions. And it was housed in a
heavy, ornate picture frame.
Clearly this was a completely different
image.
What I saw there I saw big silver frame.
You see this hoax as might call it or
copy. Everything had disappeared.
He was even denied permission to
photograph it. The Vatican have taken
their own
photos but they are rarely shown.
The reason why they don't publish this
pictures is they don't want to
disappoint the faithful by revealing
that there's no face on the Veronica
anymore. To this day, no pope has openly
admitted that the Vatican Veronica ever
disappeared or that the barely visible
face shown today is anything other than
what had always been on display.
But Paul had no doubt about what had
really happened.
It was a trick. It was a trick from the
500 years ago, from these times of
Makaveli. Paul is certain that this
trick or hoax was deliberately
perpetrated to maintain the illusion
that the Vatican still had the real
one. But if this had happened hundreds
of years ago, why not admit it now? I
think there's no question that having
the Veronica in your church if you
happen to be the pope would be an
incredibly uh useful asset. You know,
it's an item with incredible holiness
and power. Everyone is is aruck by it.
Um you're going to get a lot of people
coming to see it and it shores up your
power effectively as leader of the
church. confessing that this face has
gone lost. It was a hard thing to do
for Rome and her powerful popes. Such a
monumental loss of face would have been
deeply
embarrassing. It's a catastrophe for the
church of Rome. He lost the faith of
God. Not the faith in God, but the faith
of God.
Paul thought there may have been another
reason why the hoax was perpetrated. The
Veronica had earned the church a lot of
money. They did not come to see St.
Peter. They did not even come to see the
pope as they do today. They wanted to
see the veil.
Pilgrims had to be shown something. And
that's just what
happened. What started as a small hoax
was simply allowed to continue until it
became widely believed.
It's easy to dismiss it as just a
cynical cashing in exercise. And I'm
sure it was partly a cynical cashing in
exercise, but it was also a way of
making that pilgrimage real. I mean,
remember the whole idea of pilgrimage,
at least in theory, is to take part in
the physicality of something holy.
But others are more sympathetic about
why the Veronica might have been
replaced.
First of all, I have to disagree with
both Father Fifer and my dear friend
Paul B in the idea that the canons of
St. Peter perpetrated a hoax, a pious
forgery, a pious fraud. I do not believe
it. I believe they were hysterically
searching for something and just took
the second best and believed it because
they wanted to believe it. But visits
the right Veronica.
On April the 2nd,
2005, Pope John Paul II died. He was
succeeded by the man who had
complimented Paul on his book, Cardinal
Ratzinger, who became Pope Benedict I
16th.
On the 1st of September 2006, Pope
Benedict visited
Manipello. Often he visited Italian
shrines to to venerate the relics or or
the local traditions.
[Music]
And there's that very evocative image of
Pope Benedict just staring at at the
veil in Manopella. There's a real sense
of an encounter of a of a encountering
face to face um with Christ. He was
clearly very moved. For Paul this was
the justification for all his hard work
when he came to Monella for the first
pope. Then he prayed here in silence
about uh he bent his knee in front of it
and then for more than 8 minutes he's
been in sil prayer in front of it. I
mean it was very very
moving. It was the first
time for we believe around 500 years
that the pope saw and venerated the true
face of Christ of the resurrected
Christ.
Pope Benedict's visit changed
everything.
A week later on St. Peter Square in the
next audience he said if we want to know
who God is then we only have to look
into the face of his son and there we
see who God is and how God is. Although
not actually authenticating the image,
Pope Benedict's personal visit gave
credibility to those that believed this
was the true face of
God. He brought the image back into the
world. That's what he did.
Paul and many of the faithful believe
there is no doubting that this image is
genuine. But there will always be
skeptics. They want proper scientific
evidence to show how the image got there
and how old it is. The Guardians at
Manipello aren't against testing as long
as it is non-invasive and so doesn't
damage the
veil. They hope science will develop in
the future, allowing for a more detailed
examination, which they are sure will
vindicate their claims.
If this happens, then the veil of
Veronica would become one of the most
significant discoveries in Christian
history. Just as the Veronica was a very
popular relic in the Middle Ages, we're
now entering a new period, a revival of
this interest in in the holy face,
searching for the face of God, searching
for that personal encounter with him.
St. Paul wrote in his letters, if Christ
did not
resurrect, our faith is
worthless. So the
veneration of the Walto Santo is
concentrating the attention of
Christianity back onto the image of the
resurrected
Christ. And that's important.
[Music]
[Music]

Key Vocabulary

Start Practicing
Vocabulary Meanings

face

/feɪs/

A1
  • noun
  • - the front part of the head, including the eyes, nose, and mouth

image

/ˈɪmɪdʒ/

B1
  • noun
  • - a representation or likeness of a person or thing

veil

/veɪl/

B2
  • noun
  • - a piece of thin material worn to cover the face or head

Christ

/kraɪst/

B1
  • noun
  • - the title given to Jesus in Christianity, meaning 'the anointed one'

Vatican

/ˈvætɪkən/

B2
  • noun
  • - the residence of the Pope in Rome and the headquarters of the Catholic church

relic

/ˈrɛlɪk/

C1
  • noun
  • - an object surviving from an earlier time, especially an old religious object

pilgrimage

/ˈpɪlgrɪmɪdʒ/

B2
  • noun
  • - a journey to a holy place as an act of religious devotion

church

/tʃɜːrtʃ/

A1
  • noun
  • - a building used for Christian religious activities

history

/ˈhɪstəri/

A1
  • noun
  • - the study of past events, particularly in human affairs

miracle

/ˈmɪrəkəl/

B1
  • noun
  • - an extraordinary event that surpasses natural or scientific laws

copy

/ˈkɑːpi/

A2
  • noun
  • - a thing made to be similar to another
  • verb
  • - to make a similar version of something

frame

/freɪm/

B1
  • noun
  • - a structure that surrounds and supports something
  • verb
  • - to put a frame around something

pope

/poʊp/

B2
  • noun
  • - the head of the Catholic Church

basilica

/bəˈsɪlɪkə/

C1
  • noun
  • - a large and important church

sack

/sæk/

B2
  • noun
  • - a large bag or a plunder and destruction
  • verb
  • - to plunder or destroy a place

discover

/dɪˈskʌvər/

A2
  • verb
  • - to find or learn something new

believe

/bɪˈliːv/

A1
  • verb
  • - to accept something as true

real

/ˈriːəl/

A1
  • adjective
  • - actually existing or happening

fake

/feɪk/

B1
  • adjective
  • - not genuine; fraudulent

miraculous

/mɪˈrækjələs/

C1
  • adjective
  • - amazing and not able to be explained

Do you remember what “face” or “image” means in ""?

Hop into the app to practice now – quizzes, flashcards, and native-like pronunciation are waiting!

Key Grammar Structures

Coming Soon!

We're updating this section. Stay tuned!

Related Songs