[English]
Ambulance
[music]
service is the patient breathing.
In an emergency situation, [music] every
minute counts.
And with cardiac arrest, for every
minute that CPR isn't performed, your
chances of survival decrease by 10%.
[music]
If he's not already, lay him onto his
back on the floor. Have you done that?
>> Okay.
>> Okay. Kneel by his side
>> and put one hand flat in the center
center of his chest.
>> Put the other hand on top and lock your
fingers together. And then keeping your
arm straight, push down hard and fast.
Don't be afraid to push too hard. Push
about two times a second. Push. Push.
Say push out loud. Push. Push. Push.
Push. Push. Push. Push. Push. Push.
Really good. Push. Push. Push. Push.
Push. Push, push, push, push, push,
push, push, push. [music] Yes,
>> keep going. You're doing really well.
>> Oh, yeah. He's cropping now.
>> He's puffing.
>> Is he pushing you off?
>> Is he pushing [music] you off?
>> Yeah.
>> Okay. Okay. All right. Okay.
>> Bear with me.
>> Bear with me.
>> Put a N in the system.
>> What do I say?
>> Is he waking up?
>> Is he waking up?
>> Put it in your N.
>> [music]
>> This call handler's just saved her life.
>> Thank you so much. You did brilliantly.
Help me right out.
>> But she's also an undercover reporter
working for dispatches. [music]
>> Help me. Help. Don't help me. Don't help
me.
>> She's discovering dangerous delays.
>> She's gone into shock. I need someone
here now. I need an ambulance. Response
time is estimated to be 3 hours and 56
minutes. [music] Um, that's
>> Oh my gosh.
>> We've normalized a government
performance that would have been unheard
of before.
>> Revealing how people are let down when
they need help the most.
>> I phon the police and they're telling me
to phone you.
>> Take somebody here.
>> I made five. What do you expect me to
[music] be able to do?
>> I just look at our ambulance service
with complete mistrust. and uncovering
the difference between what callers are
told and what's really going on.
>> We're telling them that an ambulance is
being arranged,
>> but they're not actually getting an
ambulance.
>> Take care. Bye-bye. There are some
amazing parts of being a call handler,
but equally, you're also there when
things don't go right and when people
are rightfully upset and scared because
of that.
>> This is the truth about what happens
when you dial 999. [music]
>> [music]
>> We all like to believe that if you're
having a medical emergency, the NHS will
come to the rescue,
but our reporter is discovering [music]
that's not always the case.
>> Describe to me what happened. I went to
come down the stairs and I I went down
the lot from top to bottom.
>> I took a call from an 85year-old woman
with a suspected broken arm. The
computer system call handlers use is
called NHS Pathways. At first, it
recommends she gets herself to hospital.
>> Um, so someone else would need to drive
you and you would need to take any
medicine.
>> I've not got a car and I can't get
there. I need an ambulance. I'm sorry,
but I'm 85. What do you expect me to be
able [laughter] to do?
>> Call handlers aren't medically trained
and I can't overrule the computer's
instructions. So, I have to refer her to
a clinician who will decide if she
qualifies for an ambulance.
>> Get somebody here.
>> I need a clinician to call you back to
be able to assess the problem because we
need to make sure that we're getting
exactly the right help for you.
>> An ambulance is the right help to get me
to hospital to get an X-ray. So that if
it's broken, they need to put it in
plastered, won't they? I mean, you don't
have to be a clinician to work that one
out. Surely
>> because you've got the coldness in your
arm and as well as the injury that
>> Yes. But it still boils down to the same
thing, doesn't it? It needs attention
quickly.
>> Yeah. A collision will call you back as
soon as one is available. How bad does
it have to be before you do it?
>> How bad does it have to be? She's in her
80s. She's got no way to get to hospital
and she's in immense pain and she's
probably broken her arm, maybe her
shoulder.
>> I'm going to get that transferred over
now.
>> Okay, take care. Bye-bye.
As far as Pathways was concerned, she
was to refer herself to a treatment
center. And I just find it really
upsetting.
>> Such a wet wipe.
>> The simple fact that we don't have the
number of doctors and nurses we would
need to deliver the [music] model of
care we want. Increasingly, the sickest
patients are being prioritized. But what
we're seeing is that over time you have
to be sicker and sicker to get into that
top bracket.
>> The caller did eventually get an
ambulance, but we discovered that
[music] at times of extreme pressure, a
no send policy is triggered, meaning
callers will be told that although they
need an ambulance, they won't be getting
one.
>> We went into no send once during my time
undercover on a summer's evening.
139 people are waiting for a call back.
5 hours for a C2. A 68-year-old with
trauma to the head. 8 hours and 40
minutes for a 90-year-old who's in her
head. It's just hundreds of calls for
call backs.
>> Call handlers are told not to reveal the
no send [music] policy in case this
upsets patients. A supervisor explains
[music]
what to say instead. They asked them to
make their own way instead of wait for
an ambulance because we're so busy.
>> So they're telling people to make their
own way. We're not saying that we're not
giving them one. We're saying to them,
we're so busy you are going to be
waiting hours.
>> What we're seeing happening [music] in
real time is a redrawing of what is an
emergency. We're absolutely at a moment
of dire performance for health care
services, emergency [music] services in
this country.
Nationally, [music] the ambulance
service is busier than ever before.
Here at the Southeast [music] Coast
Ambulance Service, nearly a million 999
calls come in a year, [music]
but it's been struggling. And the health
watchdog says it needs improvement.
To find out why, reporter Hei Johnson is
working undercover for 8 weeks as a 999
call handler. The first voice you hear
in an emergency.
[music]
>> When people are calling 999, they can be
quite distressed, [music] upset, scared.
It's relentless. And I'm already seeing
what massive pressure the service is
under. The delays, [music] the missed
targets, the patients put at risk.
It's not just people at the bottom of
the priority pile who struggle to get an
ambulance. Those with life-threatening
[music]
conditions do too.
Because I'm new to the job, an
experienced [music] call handler is
watching over me.
>> Is the Is the patient conscious?
>> He's unresponsive completely.
>> I took one call from a mother whose son
um had type 1 diabetes. He was
unconscious. He was in a diabetic coma.
This is the third time now that I've
rung up today within the last 40
minutes.
>> It's urgent. Without swift treatment, he
could be fatal. He could suffer brain
damage or die.
>> Unconscious adult.
>> So, he's not conscious. He's not
responding to you.
>> No, he's not responding to me at all.
>> Okay.
>> The computer flags a category 2
emergency, the same level as a heart
attack.
The national NHS target for this is an
ambulance on the scene in 18 minutes,
but this call has already waited double
that.
>> If you can [music] just keep supporting
his head until help arrives or until
someone can take over.
>> The NHS as a whole has not hit the
18minute target for 5 years.
>> So, it's settled on a temporary target
of [music] 30 minutes instead.
>> Um, so we are coming as quickly as we
can. I can't imagine if that was my son
in that situation just watching them get
worse and worse. There was nothing I
could really say apart from I'm sorry
and they'll be [music] with you as soon
as they can.
>> Oh, you any other concerns just call us
back on 999. Okay.
>> The ambulance arrived soon after that
call but well outside any target time.
>> That's a bit scary.
>> Collapse.
>> Helen Morgan was elected to parliament
after campaigning to speed up Amler's
response times in Shropshire.
I don't have words for that. That's
that's really shocking. It's going to
feel like a lifetime for that mother. I
I feel desperately sorry for them. The
current weight times are well beyond the
target and that's that's not acceptable.
In the control room, a display warns
when pressure mounts.
Delays often build because ambulances
are stuck outside crowded A&E unable to
hand over patients.
Surge level three is quite a lot of
pressure on the service and it can
compromise patient care. And surge level
four is the maximum level of pressure on
the [music] service.
During my time undercover, we were
mostly at levels three [music] and four,
especially at night.
>> Oh god. 2our 13 C2 waiting for very
long. 2 hours for a C2. It's meant to
[music] be 18 minutes.
>> He's struggling. He's got a lung section
and he's struggling to breathe. Do you
think the emergency is going to be here
so much after emergency continues to be
seen now?
>> Um the current estimated wait time in
the area is an hour and 34 minutes.
That's not
>> Oh my god. No. I'll take him now. I'll
take him now. He can't bleed. We need
the ambulance now.
>> And is he conscious?
>> Uh no. He's just fallen down the stairs
and basted his head and his head's
bleeding.
>> We are extremely busy this evening and
we are experiencing delays of up to 2
hours and 11 minutes. Well, he can't
stay outside here for 2 hours. The
ground is boiling and he's laying on the
ground.
>> It's not just a problem for Southeast
Coast.
Using Freedom of Information [music]
Requests, we've discovered that last
year across England, almost 140,000
people with category 2 emergencies,
including suspected heart attacks and
strokes, waited more than 2 hours for an
ambulance. That's well outside the
18-minute target.
I regularly saw over an hour, over two
hours as the longest wait for category 2
calls. I would just expect for a heart
attack, you'd call 999 and they'd be
there. But no.
>> So, I heard you got some chest pain.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Where else is the pain?
It was in my right arm. It feels like
it's going right across his whole back
and then my like neck and just under my
jaw.
>> A man called up with chest pain. It was
likely he was having a heart attack or
experiencing some kind of cardiac
condition.
>> Yeah, it's really bad. I feel like
someone was sitting in my chest.
>> Okay. An emergency ambulance is being
arranged. Um Right.
>> Um and is is that was that your wife
earlier? Will she stay with you until
the arrives?
>> Yeah.
With a suspected heart attack, every
moment it's left untreated raises the
risk of damage to the heart or death.
>> Do you know roughly how long?
>> So, the estimated waiting time in your
area um is an hour and 45 minutes, but
that's just the longest that someone has
waited.
>> Okay. I was just wondering if I should
just try and get him there myself. I'm
just
>> That's up to you. That That's the That's
the longest waiting time. Would
we ever we So when someone says, "Oh, I
might make my own way." Then
>> what's the line there?
>> Put it back on them. That's It's up to
them.
>> So we're not allowed to say you like
it's But if they want to make their own
way, that's absolutely fine.
>> But we're not allowed to advise like
probably best for you to make your own
way.
>> The main thought is that if I was having
a heart attack, I'd want to know what
I've meant to do. You call 999 and you
sort of want clarity. You want to know
what to do. You want someone to help
you. Made me wonder what would I do?
What happened to that person? What were
they meant to do?
We tracked Chris and Amy down to [music]
find out what happened after their 999
call.
>> So, I heard you got some chest pain. Is
that right?
>> Yeah. Where else is the pain?
>> Just start getting pains in the front of
my chest. He's in the bathroom. Amy must
have got up.
>> I woke up and noticed he wasn't there.
Found him in the bathroom in lots of
pain.
>> And my arm was hurting all up around my
jaw, all up around the back of my head.
And she said, "I'm going to call you an
ambulance." Then [music]
>> the ambulance is being arranged.
>> Okay. Do you know roughly how long? So,
the estimated [music]
waiting time in your area um is an hour
and 45 minutes, but that's just the
longest that
>> I [music] was just panicked that if he
was then to go into a cardiac arrest,
>> like what would what would happen? Like,
what would we do?
>> I was just wondering whether I should
just try and get him there myself. I'm
just
>> That is completely up to you.
>> What does up to you mean? You're leaving
it in our hands and we're not medical
experts.
>> Chris and Amy waited. Eventually, an
ambulance [music] freed up and reached
them in 25 minutes.
>> Even that was [clears throat] too long.
The ambulance turn up as we was getting
ready to leave.
>> Chris was rushed to hospital and later
had a heart operation.
He's still recovering.
>> Talking to the doctor and he said, "No,
you done the right thing while waiting."
The consequence of getting in the
ambulance was they [music] took me
straight to Reus. They got the monitors
on me straight away. When you're in a
dilemma like emergency situation, which
it was, you don't know what the right
choice is.
>> In three English regions, one in 10
category 2 callers wait over an hour.
>> Just confirm you don't want the
ambulance.
>> So many can ambulances today for me.
>> Third of the calls that I took tonight
were from patients requesting to cancel
the ambulance.
people call up and then end up canceling
it because of the long waiting time. I
just find it all really troubling
>> going to hospital [music] under your own
steam. It's a workaround. That is not a
solution. Paramedics in this country are
highly trained to [music] administer at
times life-saving treatment at the
scene. So that is fundamentally
different to driving yourself to
hospital. They know the best place to
[music] take you. But I wouldn't know
that. You wouldn't know that. A
paramedic would.
in a system already at breaking point.
>> Uh just regarding a lady who's 91 who
has fallen and has been on the floor for
about 40 minutes, unable to get up.
>> What happens when you're considered the
lowest priority? [music]
>> This has been categorized as a C3
response. We aim to be with the patient
within 11 hours and 40 minutes.
So, we've just spoken to my
mother-in-law. She's not putting
sentences together. She's saying words
wrong. Um, like she just said AKO
instead of A and E.
>> Okay.
>> So, I think she might be having a
stroke.
>> When someone [music] is having a stroke,
every minute matters. Fast treatment can
be the difference [music] between life
and death or disability. That's why
strokes are category 2 emergencies with
the target response of [music] 18
minutes.
>> That emergency is being arranged and it
is running one of our high priority
calls, but we are just very busy this
evening and we are experiencing delays
of up to an hour and 12 minutes.
>> If the wait is that long, the woman
might miss out on [music] vital
treatment.
>> Hello.
>> Hello. Is the ambulance service here?
And when she comes on the line, it's
clear why she needs help. [music]
>> And could you just confirm the address
for me?
>> It's um the £3.
>> That's okay.
>> I woke up a bit strange this morning.
I'm not working properly.
Sorry, not speaking properly. I can't
keep my words straight.
>> Okay, understood.
I think the thing that shocked me most
was when she said how busy we are. That
was a real hearttoppping moment for me.
It's absolutely critical that stroke is
treated as a medical emergency because
time is brain for every minute. Nearly 2
million brain cells in the brain are
lost. And we know that the treatments
are much more effective when they're
delivered early.
>> In the case our reporter dealt with,
we've established an ambulance reached
the woman within 20 minutes. boosting
the chances of successful treatment.
But response times are a lottery. In the
Southeast Coast region, 450 suspected
stroke patients waited over 2 hours for
an ambulance last year.
And across England and Wales, dispatches
has uncovered 13,000 suspected stroke
patients also waited that long with
potentially devastating results.
[music]
>> [music]
>> I met Susan in 2015.
Such a lovely person.
We just [music] ended up seeing each
other all of the time.
Last December, Rob discovered Susan on
the floor and died 999.
Uh when my girlfriend's collapsed on the
um Susan, I think she had a stroke. She
collapsed on the toilet. Her face is
drooping on one side.
>> Okay.
>> See just slurred.
>> And I thought that was it. You know,
help would be on its way.
>> When the ambulance didn't [music]
arrive, Rob called 999 twice more.
>> I need you to tell me exactly what's
happened. [music]
>> She's had a stroke. This is the third
call I've had to make. I've reported all
the details.
>> But it took [music] 2 hours to reach
them.
That was a long time. And I thought,
[music] she's going to die here in front
of us.
It was one of the most horrible things
I've ever experienced in my life.
>> Nobody can be certain [music] if earlier
treatment would have helped. But the
ambulance response meant Susan never
stood a chance.
>> Can you lean to the left? There we go.
Let's get you get you sorted. Get that
one there.
Susan's [music] stroke has taken away
our life.
>> I can't walk and I can't use my [music]
left arm or hand.
>> Get Susan in position here.
It's also affected Susan's memory
shortterm [music] and longterm.
>> Right. Are you ready?
>> I think the crulest thing is she can't
read. [music]
>> I used to go out and do stuff. It's very
frustrating.
can't golf like I can't make him a cup
of tea or I used to make his breakfast
puppet.
>> Ready?
>> Yes. [music]
>> Steady. Stand.
>> The earlier they intervened, the less
brain damage Susan would have [music]
had.
Southwest Ambulance Service told us they
offer their sincere [music] apologies to
Susan. They say the delay was
unacceptable, but at the time their
service was under extreme pressure.
What happened to Susan could happen
[music] to anyone.
I would like to think we could trust in
our ambulance service, but I just look
at them with complete [music] mistrust.
I mean, it's not acceptable.
>> The really sad [music] thing is that Rob
and Susan's quality of life is seriously
impaired. Her outcome could have been so
very, very different.
We are seeing unacceptable [music]
delays in ambulance response times. And
for those patients who miss out on the
treatment window, it's heartbreaking.
>> Not every 99 call is life or death.
About one in five are what the ambulance
service terms category 3es. Urgent calls
including falls, assaults, or mental
health incidents. The target is to
respond to most within 2 hours.
>> I fell uh last night and I can't get up.
So,
>> okay. I'm see you on the floor right
now.
>> Yes.
>> Many of these callers are in terrible
pain and need urgent assessment. I can
see his ligament or his muscles or
something actually moving within his
leg.
>> So, uh, I just cut my leg on a piece of
glass here and and it's like really
really deep. It's got really bad really
hurt.
>> You need to stay calm. I can't arrange
whether she stay calm.
>> They often lose [music] out because
ambulances are diverted to more
life-threatening emergencies.
>> We're not moving any more than on her
back because her foot is at a right
angle to where it should be.
>> An emergency ambulance has been
arranged. The response time is estimated
to be 3 hours and 56 minutes. [music]
Um,
>> oh my god.
>> The NHS target is to [music] reach most
of these cases within 2 hours.
>> Figures seen by dispatches showed
[music] that at Southeast Coast 1 in 10
take 4 and 1/2 hours. One of the worst
figures in the country.
>> So it should [music] be 2 hours roughly.
So we should get to that patient in 2
hours. But do we ever get to that
patient in 2 hours? No.
>> During my 19 shifts undercover, there
were always cat 3s with massively long
wait times.
>> And what's the reason for the call?
>> We're in the middle of the field. The
boy fell down from the bicycle and I can
see the bones under the skin that's
sticking out.
[music]
>> The mother called on behalf of her
teenage son and she was by herself and
scared. They'd been on a walk. He was
fell off his bike and [music] broke
either his collarbone or his shoulder.
Um he was on the floor and couldn't
move.
So an emergency ambulance has been
arranged and the response time is
estimated to be 6 hours. We're it might
not be that long, but that's the longest
that someone has had to wait in your
area.
The estimated waiting time was 6 hours,
which if right would have them picked up
by the ambulance at 2:00 a.m. in the
morning.
>> Okay. And is there any way to know what
it's going to be here before that?
Because he is in pain. Pain.
>> He is on the ground on his back. He
can't move.
>> We're extremely busy at the moment.
>> I understand that, but we've got no way
of getting out of here.
>> We don't know if the boy ever got an
ambulance, and if so, how long it took.
But we've discovered almost all category
3 calls are sent to clinicians who will
phone patients back to [music] see if an
ambulance is really necessary.
Although the callers are told something
different
>> to offer further support. A clinician
will try to call you back to do a
further clinical assessment whilst you
wait.
>> I was taken through this validation
process during my training.
>> Cat please were saying an ambulance
response is arranged. However, from what
we think you'd benefit from further
clinical assessments, so we'll get a
clinician to call you back. They will
then go into a validation stack. The
clinicians will review it and they might
sand it down and they'll deal with that.
Which is why we never say an ambulance
is on its way.
>> Well, if I was told that an ambulance is
being arranged, I would immediately be
thinking that an ambulance is either on
its way to me already or being
redirected to me. I wouldn't immediately
be thinking people are still debating
whether or not I need an ambulance in
the first place.
[music]
>> We've discovered this process has been
implemented across England.
At Southeast Coast, clinicians are
supposed to review these cases within 30
minutes.
>> These are patients that should be called
back as soon as possible.
But sometimes we
have them wait for hours and all of them
they are like poorly. I've seen calls
waiting for 7 hours and it's a
validation call.
>> If you send somebody to a triage and
it's a very serious issue and you need
an ambulance to come straight away, then
that triage needs to happen quickly. If
people are waiting hours and hours for
the triage, then I would I would say
that was ineffective.
Southeast Coast Ambulance Service told
us they've made measurable progress over
the last 3 years, resulting in category
2 response times averaging 28 minutes,
better than the national standard.
They say there is more to do to reduce
our waiting times further and now
[music] give clearer information.
They apologize to any patient whose
experience has fallen short of the
standards we work hard to deliver. And
no, prolonged delays can cause
additional distress.
The national [music] mental health
crisis is adding to the stress on the
999 system.
>> I've phoned the police and they're
telling me to phone you.
>> And patients are falling between the
cracks of the emergency services. This
man is in serious danger.
>> And what's the reason for the call?
>> Potential overdose. And she's currently
slicing her wrist with a knife in front
of me.
>> Of the roughly 400 calls I took, I was
struck by how many related to mental
health and how serious they were.
So, at the moment, what are you most
concerned about? Is it is it your mental
health?
>> Yeah, I will kill myself tomorrow.
>> I took about 50 tablets.
>> Was that um an attempt to end your life?
>> Yes.
>> Most mental health calls get a lower
priority category 3 response.
>> Oh god. Longest weight 11 hours. The
longest C3 wait that I've seen has been
like 11 and 1/2 hours. Someone telling
you that they want to end their life.
Hearing that over the phone and then
knowing that they could be waiting hours
and hours for an ambulance. It's a
really hard part about the job.
>> She's got quite a robust plan involving
taking an overdose.
>> Okay.
>> And I'm extremely concerned about her.
>> I took a call from a mental health
worker who had spoken to someone with
plans to end [music] their life. There
really is some risk clear.
>> Okay. Yeah, understood. Like I said, an
emergency ambulance has been arranged
and it's being [music] categorized as a
C3 response. Um, but in the meantime, I
am going to try and call her to assess
her [music] directly.
>> And what what's the main problem at the
moment?
>> It's just my mental health, that's all.
>> And have things got so bad that you're
thinking about ending up your life?
>> Yes, definitely. Yes. Don't want to go
through it again. I'm not going to go
through that again. I'm just going to
take my time and just end my life. I
just don't want it anymore.
>> Do you feel like During the training, we
only had 1 hour on mental health and it
totally failed to prepare me for the
complexity of those calls. The computer
told me to talk to her reassuringly,
>> but I felt helpless and I remember
thinking, gosh, I'd like some training
for this.
Until recently, the police might have
helped [music] with a welfare check,
but we've discovered serious concerns
about [music] a new national policy
intended to free up police resources to
fight crime.
The right care, right person [music]
scheme introduced in 2023 means police
now only respond when there is an
immediate risk to life or of serious
harm.
In theory, this policy is a [music]
positive thing because often the police
are not the right people to respond when
someone's in a mental health crisis. And
a lot of the time it can be quite
stigmatizing to have police arrive
[music] when when you haven't committed
a crime. You're just really struggling.
However, you're seeing [music]
um millions of hours of police time
being removed
and the [music] health services,
voluntary service are being expected to
step in, but with no additional [music]
resource.
Our reporter encountered situations
where desperate callers couldn't get
help from the police or the NHS, leaving
them confused [music] about where to
turn to during a mental health crisis.
Ambulance
service. Is the patient breathing?
>> I don't know.
>> A woman concerned for her suicidal
friend called in.
>> Okay. Could I take the address? His
address.
>> I don't know. I phoned the police and
they said you have to liaz with them.
>> We need We need an address to be able to
send an ambulance.
I don't know the address. I've phoned
the police
>> and they're telling me to phone you.
>> I know. I'm sorry.
>> To lies with them.
>> I'm afraid that
>> this man is in serious danger.
>> I understand. I'm really I know this is
really difficult. I'm afraid that's not
how it works. We can't send an ambulance
unless we have an address.
>> Um but
>> they told me you would phone them cuz
you have his address. No, they'd have to
if you phoned them, they would have to
phone us.
>> The police know that we can't arrange
help without an address.
>> If they're a suicide risk and they could
kill themselves, then every minute
wasted sending people back and forth
between services is a minute that
[music] puts them more at risk.
>> We don't have the facilities to be able
to find his address, whereas the police
do.
>> It's just not good enough, is it? being
passed between the police and ambulance
service is just not okay. It is
absolutely critical that those
partnerships are strong and that there's
really clear communication. This call is
evidence of serious shortcomings in in
the implementation of the right care
right person policy because ultimately
people in a mental health crisis in an
emergency situation are falling through
the gaps between services.
At least six coroners have issued
reports flagging concerns about the
policy and detailing how officers were
not deployed to vulnerable people in
urgent need. [music]
>> Time and again, it wasn't clear whether
a mental health call would be dealt with
by the police officers or ambulance
crews. [music]
>> My wife seems like she's suffering some
kind of um maybe mental breakdown. She's
talking to herself. Um, she's saying
some very nasty things to everybody.
It's just scaring everybody. I'm
concerned, you know, for my kids and
obviously my elderly parents.
>> Do you think that she could like harm or
attack anyone?
>> Yes, I think she could.
>> My computer flagged [music] the police
should attend because of the potential
risk of violence.
>> With the help of my mentor, I give them
a call.
>> Control room. Hi, Cam.
>> Hi. Um, can we request your attendance,
please? But the police control [music]
room say they won't send anyone.
>> I have clarified with my team leader
that it is you to attend first of all
and then if your crew feel threatened
when they arrive on scene, then they
call us for attendance.
[music]
>> It's decided a clinician will call the
man back. But for now, neither police
nor ambulance are on their way.
Southeast Coast Ambulance told us
they're working to improve the
experience of those we care for with
mental health needs and that they are
working with partners on how these calls
are [music] prioritized and managed.
The National Police Chief's Council said
the right care, right person policy
makes sure our communities receive an
appropriate response from the
professionals who are best equipped to
support them.
Police will always respond where there
is a real and immediate risk to the life
of a person or risk of serious harm.
>> I'm sure there are incidents that the
police still attend, but in the vast
majority it feels as if ambulance
workers have just been abandoned and
left to deal with all incidents on their
own. And we believe it the whole policy
needs to be reviewed.
>> His temperature is 39.1. His condition
is worsening.
>> Okay. How old is he?
>> He's two.
>> In the control center, staff work
12-hour shifts and the pace is
unrelenting.
>> What's the reason for the call?
>> I'm bringing up um ground poo and the
plane is absolutely excruciating.
>> But across the country, when [music]
mistakes are made, families are left
fighting for answers. When it goes
wrong, they do gaslight and they do lie.
[screaming]
[music] We've seen up close the
pressures on the ambulance service and
how they put lives at risk.
But when errors result in tragedy,
[music] the truth is sometimes hidden.
Claire is [music] grieving for her
35year-old son, Martin.
[music]
>> Martin likes to potter in the garden.
It was something that we had in common.
Martin was born in 1987 [music] and John
in 1989.
Martin [music] was funny, very dry.
He was just Martin. He was our our first
born.
>> In December 2022, John found his brother
Martin unconscious in the house they
shared.
John had [music] training for CPR. So he
started to do that and ring 999
spoke to the call handler. The call
handler ended the call. So John was able
to quickly ring me.
From him ringing to me getting there was
probably 25 [music] minutes.
There was no no ambulance on site. So I
ran into the house and a site [music]
that nobody wants to see. My youngest
son doing chest compressions on his
brother, you know, and obviously I said
to John, "Where are they?" And he said,
"I don't know." I thought, "Right, I've
just got to ring them back.
As a result of that second call, an
ambulance was then dispatched. I think
the first responder turned up about 12
minutes later.
She didn't try any intervention and just
sort of commented, "Oh, no, he's
deceased."
>> [music]
>> A postmortem later revealed that Martin
died of a condition called [music]
ketoacidosis
which caused a cardiac arrest.
[music]
>> You can't help but wonder if they'd have
got there sooner, perhaps they could
have done [music] something for him.
Martin lived [music] just half a mile
from Wales's biggest hospital, but it
took the ambulance 45 minutes to get
[music] to him. We put a complaint in
very, very quickly and right from the
beginning. They completely pull the
shutters down and [music]
it is entirely about protecting the
trust. It's torturous.
The Welsh Shawn [music] budsman launched
an investigation and concluded there had
been a series of errors, including the
first [music] ambulance being stood down
and that without them it was possible
Martin might have survived.
Clare discovered that something called
[music] intelligent routting platform or
IRP was in effect the week Martin died.
It rooted calls from overwhelmed 999
call handlers in England onto their
Welsh counterparts.
There were days [music] when there was
something like 600 calls coming in and
that's in addition to our own nation's
calls. [music]
The system was so overloaded a critical
incident had to be declared. [music] I
am quite convinced that it h it did have
an impact.
>> The ombbudsman also criticized the Welsh
Ambulance Service for withholding
evidence.
Why shouldn't we know exactly [music]
what went on and why?
Believe you me, when it goes wrong, they
do gaslight and they do lie. They use
your grief and your anxiety to get you
to a point where they're hoping [music]
you'll give up. It's not a bit about the
berieved family. They really don't
[music] care.
The Welsh Amberland service says IRP had
limited impact [music] on their call
handling ability, but acknowledges its
failings and accepts the ombbudsman's
findings. It takes its responsibilities
to be open and honest very seriously and
recognizes CLA feels let down for which
it is deeply sorry.
[music] There's concern about ambulance
service coverups across the country.
Paul Calver, a former police detective,
[music]
worked inside the Northeast Ambulance
Service with the job of giving
information to coroners and families
about [music] sudden unexplained deaths.
I first became suspicious of concerns
with the trust altering or concealing
documents from coroners and families
fairly early on. There was
irregularities with paperwork or missing
paperwork and items that should have
been supplied with the coroner and
hadn't been. I found that the trust were
altering concealing documents in
relation to [music] patient deaths and
which has occurred due to potential
mistakes that they'd made.
>> Paul turned whistleblower among the
cover-ups he highlighted and to [music]
which Northeast Ambulance Service has
now admitted the death of 17-year-old
Quinn [music] Milbour Beedle. The
paramedic on the scene failed to perform
life-saving treatment [music]
despite her still having a pulse.
Another involved 62-year-old granddad
Peter Coats, who died [music] after his
crucial oxygen machine lost power and
the paramedics sent to help stopped for
a long unscheduled break.
[music]
It's impossible to say how many deaths
may have followed a similar pattern. One
thing I can say with [music] certainty
is 5-year period at the trust. The trust
under reported um serious incidents when
a certain level of harm or suspected
harm [music] occurs to a patient.
That also means there wouldn't [music]
have been an investigation. So therefore
no learning would have been taken from
that patient's death. So then that death
incident is likely to [music] reoccur.
It means the family can't um obtain
justice or answers for how their loved
one came about the death.
I'd still get contacted by families
raising concerns about other trusts.
This is an ongoing issue. In [music] my
opinion, it seems as though we live in a
coverup culture.
Northeast Ambulance Service told us it
had given an unreserved apology to the
families it failed
and had addressed the flaws [music] in
its processes.
And I fundamentally [music] believe that
unless we get to the point where every
part of the NHS
is willing and able to be open about the
errors that are sometimes inevitable,
how can we have a system that's going to
keep improving, that's going to learn.
>> I'm nearing the end of my 8 weeks
working undercover as a 999 call
handler. It's a really privileged
position to have. You are sometimes
there for the beginning of someone's
life or for the end of someone's life.
But equally, you're also there when
things don't go right [music] and when
people are upset and scared because of
that.
>> Sometimes it's the supposedly lower
priority calls [music] when every moment
counts but in a different way that
really affect you.
>> Go ahead with the reason for the call.
>> The hospice um asked for an ambulance to
pick my husband up at 10:00 this
morning. They said it would be an
accidental of 2 hours. It's now been
nearly fine. He's he's dying and they've
got a bed for the hospice.
>> Okay, understood.
>> They'd arranged it as a 2-hour response
and his wife was calling up because
she'd waited over 5 and 1/2 [music]
hours.
>> I can't give an ETA. I could see that an
ambulance hadn't even been allocated or
assigned to this job. So, I had no way
of telling how much longer this woman
and her husband were going to be
waiting.
All he needed was to go to the hospice
to be somewhere comfortable.
>> I don't have access to any like exact
ETAs, but I can see um that it is still
arranged and they they will be with you
as soon as a crew becomes available and
I will make a note of the fact that
you've called back.
>> Thank you for finding out for me. That's
really kind of you.
>> It just feels pretty basic. It feels
like a matter of just like dignity. Um
just get someone to a comfortable place
where they can die.
She was so nice. Thank you for looking
up for me.
>> Thanks so much for looking out for me. I
was like, "No, that's fine." I mean, I
literally told you I don't know.
>> Dispatches has witnessed 999 under
severe pressure even before winter
arrives.
>> We described it as a perma crisis in the
NHS. We're at risk, I think, of becoming
desensitized to some of these awful
stories because they're so [music]
common. And there needs to be a clear
plan now to say not again, not this
winter. We need to end
the crisis in emergency care [music] and
and get a grip of what's happening
throughout the health system.
The government has launched a 10-year
plan to transform the NHS, [music]
warning it must reform or die. But the
problems of the ambulance service are
immediate.
>> Fundamentally, the 10-year plan is a
vision of a very different health care
service [music]
in the medium term. Problems we have of
long wait for an ambulance aren't
[music] going to be immediately solved
by that 10-year plan.
Unfortunately, I think part of the deal
is recognizing that we won't receive the
same level of care we used to. that long
weights are going to be a feature of
[music] the next few years and there's
probably just no way around that.
>> The Department of Health and Social Care
told [music] us it is turning things
around. Ambulance response times are the
fastest since the [music] pandemic.
Backed by450 million pounds, it is
[music] expanding urgent and emergency
capacity to cut delays.
I think everyone in the ambulance
service is doing their best. I just
think they don't have enough to do the
best job possible.
I think one of the most shocking things
for me is how unshocked everyone who
works there is by the situation.
People aren't surprised by the long
waiting times.
People aren't surprised by people
becoming really upset and distressed on
the phone. It It's so normal now. People
are just so used to it being like this.