[English]
This is Alcatraz Island.
The Rock.
Home to America’s most infamous prison.
It long stood as a symbol of
confinement and inescapable fate.
But it’s also a place of radical change,
the site of perhaps the most important
event in modern Native American history.
More than a protest, it was a catalyst
that helped bring the relationship
between the American government and
Native nations into a brand new era.
One that we’re still feeling the effects of today.
Hi! I'm Che Jim, and welcome to
Crash Course Native American History.
[THEME MUSIC]
In previous episodes, we covered a lot of friction
between the U.S. government
and Native American peoples.
There were broken treaties and
forced removal to reservations.
The attempted elimination of Native cultures
through assimilation and allotment.
Efforts to repair things that fell short,
like the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934.
And then sweeping reversals of
previous agreements with the Termination Era.
Things were…pretty bad.
For, like, centuries.
So by the 1960s, tensions were high
between Native nations and the U.S. government.
Native groups, like the American Indian
Movement and Red Power Movement,
had risen up to try to make change.
Power to the people!
And in November 1969, a group of Native Americans,
calling themselves Indians of All Tribes,
took over and occupied Alcatraz Island
in the San Francisco Bay for 19 months.
That’s over a year and a half.
Side note, Alcatraz Island was originally home
to the Muwekma Ohlone Tribe…
for about 10,000 years before
the Spanish “discovered” it.
Richard Oakes, one of the
group’s leaders, said in a statement,
“The choice now lies with the leaders
of the American government
— to use violence upon us, as before,
to remove us from our Great Spirit's land,
or to institute a real change in
its dealing with the American Indian.”
Basically, the ball is in your court.
And here’s the thing: it worked.
A year after the occupation began,
then-president Richard Nixon announced plans
for a sweeping new policy for
dealing with Native nations.
One that would return power to tribal authorities
and reaffirm Native sovereignty.
It was time to enter our Self-Determination Era.
This period, which began in the
late ’60s and continues to this day,
is defined by Native American activism.
Activism pushing for the
honoring of previous treaties,
more autonomy over how we’re governed,
and more control over resources on tribal lands.
In other words, activism pushing
for the ability to self-determine.
Solid name.
But before we dive into the good – and bad –
of this new era of federal Indian policy,
let's zoom out a little.
For decades, the U.S.
government had entrusted itself
with the welfare of Native nations.
A relationship that was established
by treaties and policies,
and reinforced by Supreme Court cases.
The bulk of that trust relationship was maintained
by the Bureau of Indian Affairs, or BIA.
But many Native nations had never stopped fighting
for their inherent right to self-govern.
And while protest movements like the occupation
of Alcatraz helped to finally push policy forward,
self-determination had been the
goal of many tribal leaders for years.
Like, in the early 60’s, the Zuni
Nation of what’s now New Mexico
found a legal loophole that
allowed them to take more control
over critical community services
typically handled by the BIA.
By replacing federal employees
with elected Tribal Leaders,
the Nation gained more say in its own governance.
Nixon actually pointed to the success of the Zuni
in his speech calling for
self-determination, saying quote,
“The time has now come to build on these
experiences and to extend local Indian control.”
In 1975, Nixon’s proposal became a reality through
The Indian Self-Determination
and Education Assistance Act.
And as of 2024, self-determination remains the
driving policy behind U.S/tribal relations.
We determine ourselves, thank you very much.
But what does this actually
mean for Native Americans?
Basically, self-determination
allows Native nations
more control over social services
like schools, first responders,
and healthcare clinics.
The federal government still maintains oversight
– and the process is convoluted,
to say the least –
but it’s no longer fully in charge of these
essential parts of tribal communities.
The federal government is also
required to consult with Native nations
any time they plan to propose a policy
that would directly involve them.
Or, take education.
For over a hundred years,
the government ran, or outsourced,
Indian boarding schools that focused
primarily on erasing Native culture,
and absorbing Natives into American culture
— a process called assimilation.
This was often accompanied by physical,
sexual, and emotional violence.
There’s much more on this in episode 12.
But in the era of self-determination, most tribes
were able to take over
governance of BIA-run schools,
radically altering the way
Native youth were taught.
That meant ditching the old assimilation tactics
and turning tribal-run schools into
places of community and healing.
For example, in what’s now Oklahoma,
the Riverside Indian School
once forced Native students
to cut their hair and punished
them for speaking their languages.
Today, Native students there are
learning about their history and culture –
participating in traditional dances and songs,
and wearing customary clothing like
moccasins and ribbon dresses.
Some of the former students have
even returned to serve as teachers,
helping to undo the harm of the past.
And while the school is still
technically operated by the BIA,
thanks to self-determination laws,
its day-to-day operation is run by local
Native administrators and teachers.
Core subjects are also being filtered through
a Native lens thanks to this new structure.
Like, using the teachings
of Yup’ik Elders in Alaska,
some schools have connected their
math curriculum to cultural knowledge
by teaching about geometry
using a traditional salmon rack.
By combining culture with
context, students are able
to better connect with
abstract mathematical formulas.
And many tribes are finding that
teaching in Native languages
or using Native cultural touchstones
actually reinforces other areas of learning.
At the Rock Point chapter
of the Navajo Reservation
in what’s now northern Arizona,
all classes are taught in the
native language of Navajo.
Children learn everything from math to
grammar in the language of their ancestors.
It’s part of a recent effort to
revitalize the Navajo language.
And not only does it do wonders
for the language itself,
but researchers found that students at Rock Point
scored higher in math compared
to kids on other reservations.
They even scored higher in English!
Other steps were taken to protect
Native children during this period, too.
Like, in 1978, just a few years
into the era of self-determination,
Congress passed the Indian Child Welfare Act.
This made it easier for a Native
child to be placed with a relative,
tribal foster agency, or other
member of their Native nation.
It was passed in response to
a congressional investigation
which found Native children
were “removed from their homes
at much higher rates than non-Native children.”
Often, they were placed with non-Native
families and in non-Native communities.
And arguably, there’s no better resource for
Native children than their families and tribes.
Children raised by relatives are far more likely
to live in a stable environment and more likely
to be employed or in school by age 21.
And they’re less likely to
be unhoused or incarcerated.
But before you go thinking
that the self-determination era
is all glitter and roses, there
have been – and still are – issues.
Remember, during the previous era of termination,
lots of Native nations lost
their federal recognition.
Which meant the federal government ended the
nation-to-nation relationship
they had with those tribes.
Which also meant they could no longer apply
for funding and grants through the new policies.
So not every tribe gets to experience
the positive effects of self-determination.
And then, there was corruption and
fiscal mismanagement within the BIA itself.
In the 1980s, George H.W.
Bush’s administration organized
the Special Committee to
Investigate American Indian Affairs.
And in 1989 it released a
report that found, quote,
“fraud, corruption, and mismanagement”
were pervasive within the BIA – as well as
within tribal governments themselves.
In the intervening years, Congress passed
a number of amendments to the original
Indian Self-Determination law designed
to address some of these issues.
Passed in 1988, one amendment further protected
the ability of tribes to contract
and manage federal programs
for themselves and to use
funds as they deem necessary.
Other later amendments
established Tribal Self-Governance
as a permanent program within the
Department of the Interior (or DOI)
and the Department of Health
and Human Services (or DHHS).
These amendments gave Tribal
Leaders more oversight
in the way funds were actually
being spent on tribal programs.
Which is what they should have had all along. So, that brings us to today.
It’s now been over 50 years since Native activists
sailed into the waters of the San Francisco Bay
and claimed an island prison as their own.
In 2015, one of the original occupiers,
Jonny Bearcub of the
Assiniboine and Sioux Nations,
spoke at the 45th anniversary gathering.
"Alcatraz was the beginning [...]
it was also giving permission
to everybody in Indian country
that it's okay, you can stand up for your rights.”
In the years that followed,
plenty of Natives heeded that call,
pushing the U.S. government toward a more
just relationship with Native nations.
And that work is ongoing.
For example, the National Association
of Food Distribution Programs
on Indian Reservations consults with
the U.S. Department of Agriculture
to advocate for better access
to fresh and traditional foods.
That includes increasing tribal
control to source healthier options
in the food packages serving Native communities.
Because here’s the thing, self-determination
policies have done a lot for Native nations.
They’ve given us more control
over our tribal governments,
allowed us to provide education to
our youth through cultural context,
and helped keep Native
children with Native families.
But they haven’t been a cure-all.
There are still unrecognized treaties,
unceded lands, and legacies of injustice.
But the good thing is, there are still people
willing to fight for a better world.
And who knows?
Maybe in the years to come, we’ll find another
path forward and we’ll enter a brand new era.
In our next episode, we’re going
to explore some of the ways
modern Federal Indian Policy
impacts Natives today.
And I’ll see you then.
Thanks for watching this episode of
Crash Course Native American History,
which was filmed at our studio
in Indianapolis, Indiana,
and was made with the help
of all these nice people.
If you want to help keep Crash
Course free for everyone,
forever, you can join our community on Patreon.