Speaker:
Through your achievements
and your words,
00:01
you've inspired and encouraged our nation to become a more
00:03
In these difficult times, you have challenged us to open our
00:09
minds and work together
to reach common ground.
00:12
Your life exemplifies the
power of education to create new
00:17
opportunities and to offer significant contributions to our society.
00:21
For all you have accomplished and for your leadership of this
00:27
great nation, the University of Michigan is deeply honored to
00:31
present you with the honorary degree, Doctor of Laws.
00:36
(cheers and applause)
00:41
Speaker:
By the authority of the state of Michigan vested in the Board of
00:56
Regents and by them delegated
to me, I now confer upon you,
01:00
Barack H. Obama, the
degree Doctor of Laws,
01:04
and admit you to all of its rights, honors, and privileges.
01:07
(cheers and applause)
01:15
The President:
Thank you.
01:29
(cheers and applause)
01:30
(cheers and applause)
01:36
Thank you very much.
01:40
(cheers and applause)
01:42
(cheers and applause)
01:48
Thank you very much; thank you.
01:50
Thank you, everybody.
01:53
Audience Member:
We love you!
01:56
The President:
I love you back.
01:58
It is great to be here
in the Big House --
02:03
(cheers and applause)
02:08
-- and so may I say, "Go Blue!"
02:13
(cheers and applause)
02:15
I thought I'd go for the cheap
applause line to start things off.
02:24
Good afternoon, President
Coleman, the Board of Trustees,
02:34
to faculty, parents, family and
friends of the class of 2010.
02:37
Congratulations on
your graduation,
02:47
and thank you for allowing me
the honor of being a part of it.
02:50
Let me acknowledge your
wonderful governor,
02:59
Jennifer Granholm --
03:01
-- your mayor, John Hieftje; and all the members of Congress who
03:09
It is a privilege to be with you
on this happy occasion, and,
03:15
you know, it's nice to spend
a little time outside of Washington.
03:19
Now, don't get me wrong -- Washington is a beautiful city.
03:26
It's very nice living
above the store;
03:33
you can't beat the commute.
03:36
It's just sometimes all you hear
in Washington is the clamor of politics.
03:45
And all that noise can drown out
the voices of the people who
03:51
So when I took office, I decided
that each night I would read 10
03:57
letters out of the tens of
thousands that are sent to us by
04:03
ordinary Americans every day
-- this is my modest effort to
04:07
remind myself of why I
ran in the first place.
04:11
Some of these letters tell
stories of heartache and struggle.
04:16
Some express gratitude,
some express anger.
04:22
I'd say a good solid
third call me an idiot --
04:28
-- which is how I know
that I'm getting a good,
04:32
representative sample.
04:34
(laughter and applause)
04:36
Some of the letters
make you think --
04:49
like the one that I received
last month from a kindergarten
04:52
Now, the teacher of this class
instructed the students to ask
04:58
me any question they wanted.
05:01
So one asked, "How
do you do your job?"
05:04
Another asked, "Do
you work a lot?"
05:10
Somebody wanted to know if I
wear a black jacket or if I have a beard --
05:16
-- so clearly they were getting me mixed up with the other tall
05:26
And one of my favorites was from
a kid who wanted to know if I
05:41
lived next to a volcano.
05:46
I'm still trying to piece the
thought process on this one.
05:52
But it was the last question
from the last student in the
06:05
letter that gave me pause.
06:08
The student asked, "Are
people being nice?"
06:11
Are people being nice?
06:17
Well, if you turn on the
news today, or yesterday,
06:20
or a week ago, or a month ago -- particularly one of the cable channels --
06:26
-- you can see why even a kindergartener would ask this question.
06:33
We've got politicians calling
each other all sorts of
06:40
unflattering names.
06:43
Pundits and talking heads
shout at each other.
06:45
The media tends to play
up every hint of conflict,
06:50
because it makes for
a sexier story --
06:53
which means anyone interested in
getting coverage feels compelled
06:55
to make their arguments as
outrageous and as incendiary as possible.
06:58
Now, some of this
contentiousness can be
07:07
attributed to the incredibly
difficult moment in which we
07:11
find ourselves as a nation.
07:14
The fact is, when you leave here
today you will search for work
07:17
in an economy that is still
emerging from the worst crisis
07:21
since the Great Depression.
07:24
You live in a century where
the speed with which jobs and
07:27
industries move across the globe
is forcing America to compete
07:30
You will raise your children
at a time when threats like
07:36
terrorism and climate change
aren't confined within the
07:38
borders of any one country.
07:42
And as our world grows
smaller and more connected,
07:45
you will live and work with more
people who don't look like you
07:49
or think like you or
come from where you do.
07:53
I really enjoyed Alex's remarks
because that's a lot of change.
07:59
And all these changes,
all these challenges,
08:05
inevitably cause some
tension in the body politic.
08:08
They make people worry about the
future and sometimes they get
08:13
But I think it's important
that we maintain some historic perspective.
08:21
Since the days of our founding,
American politics has never been
08:26
a particularly nice business.
08:31
It's always been a little less
gentile during times of great change.
08:36
A newspaper of the opposing
party once editorialized that if
08:42
Thomas Jefferson were elected,
"Murder, robbery, rape,
08:45
adultery, and incest will be
openly taught and practiced."
08:50
Opponents of Andrew Jackson
often referred to his mother as
09:02
a "common prostitute," which
seems a little over the top.
09:06
Presidents from Teddy Roosevelt
to Lyndon Johnson have been
09:15
accused of promoting
socialism, or worse.
09:18
And we've had arguments between
politicians that have been
09:22
settled with actual duels.
09:24
There was even a caning once on
the floor of the United States
09:28
Senate -- which I'm happy to say didn't happen while I was there.
09:30
It was a few years before.
09:35
The point is, politics has never
been for the thin-skinned or the
09:43
faint-of-heart, and if
you enter the arena,
09:47
you should expect
to get roughed up.
09:50
Moreover, democracy in a nation
of more than 300 million people
09:54
is inherently difficult.
09:59
It's always been noisy and
messy, contentious, complicated.
10:02
We've been fighting about
the proper size and role of
10:08
government since the days
the Framers gathered in Philadelphia.
10:10
We've battled over the meaning
of individual freedom and
10:16
equality since the Bill
of Rights was drafted.
10:18
As our economy has shifted
emphasis from agriculture to
10:22
industry, to information,
to technology,
10:25
we have argued and struggled at
each and every juncture over the
10:28
best way to ensure that all of
our citizens have a shot at opportunity.
10:32
So before we get too depressed
about the current state of our
10:38
politics, let's
remember our history.
10:40
The great debates of the past
all stirred great passions.
10:45
They all made somebody angry,
and at least once led to a
10:48
What is amazing is that
despite all the conflict,
10:56
despite all its flaws
and its frustrations,
11:01
our experiment in democracy has
worked better than any form of
11:03
government on Earth.
11:08
On the last day of the
Constitutional Convention,
11:23
Benjamin Franklin was famously
asked, "Well, Doctor,
11:26
what have we got -- a
republic or a monarchy?"
11:30
And Franklin gave an answer
that's been quoted for ages: He
11:35
said, "A republic,
if you can keep it."
11:39
If you can keep it.
11:44
Well, for more than 200
years, we have kept it.
11:47
Through revolution and civil
war, our democracy has survived.
11:50
Through depression and world
war, it has prevailed.
11:55
Through periods of great
social and economic unrest,
11:59
from civil rights
to women's rights,
12:01
it has allowed us slowly,
sometimes painfully,
12:04
to move towards a
more perfect union.
12:08
And so now, class of 2010, the
question for your generation is
12:12
this: How will you keep
our democracy going?
12:16
At a moment when our challenges
seem so big and our politics
12:24
seem so small, how will you keep
our democracy alive and vibrant;
12:26
how will you keep it
well in this century?
12:33
I'm not here to offer some
grand theory or detailed policy prescription.
12:38
But let me offer a few brief
reflections based on my own
12:44
experiences and the experiences
of our country over the last two centuries.
12:46
First of all, American democracy
has thrived because we have
12:53
recognized the need for a
government that, while limited,
12:57
can still help us adapt
to a changing world.
13:02
On the fourth panel of the
Jefferson Memorial is a quote I
13:07
remember reading to my daughters
during our first visit there.
13:11
It says, "I am not an advocate
for frequent changes in laws and
13:15
constitutions, but...with
the change of circumstances,
13:20
institutions must advance also
to keep pace with the times."
13:25
The democracy designed by
Jefferson and the other founders
13:31
was never intended to solve
every problem with a new law or
13:34
Having thrown off the tyranny
of the British Empire,
13:40
the first Americans were
understandably skeptical of government.
13:42
And ever since we've held fast
to the belief that government
13:46
doesn't have all the answers,
and we have cherished and
13:49
fiercely defended our
individual freedom.
13:52
That's a strand of
our nation's DNA.
13:54
But the other strand is the
belief that there are some
13:58
things we can only do
together, as one nation --
14:01
and that our government must
keep pace with the times.
14:04
When America expanded from a few
colonies to an entire continent,
14:09
and we needed a way
to reach the Pacific,
14:13
our government helped
build the railroads.
14:15
When we transitioned from an
economy based on farms to one
14:20
based on factories, and workers
needed new skills and training,
14:23
our nation set up a system
of public high schools.
14:26
When the markets crashed during
the Depression and people lost
14:32
their life savings, our
government put in place a set of
14:35
rules and safeguards to make
sure that such a crisis never
14:38
happened again, and then put a
safety net in place to make sure
14:41
that our elders would never be
impoverished the way they had been.
14:45
And because our markets and
financial systems have evolved
14:52
since then, we're now putting in
place new rules and safeguards
14:55
to protect the American people.
14:58
Now, this notion --
15:01
This notion, class, hasn't always been partisan.
15:11
It was the first Republican
President, Abraham Lincoln,
15:15
who said the role of government
is to do for the people what
15:19
they cannot do better
for themselves.
15:22
And he'd go on to begin that
first intercontinental railroad
15:25
and set up the first
land-grant colleges.
15:28
It was another Republican,
Teddy Roosevelt, who said,
15:32
"the object of government is
the welfare of the people."
15:35
And he's remembered for using
the power of government to break
15:39
up monopolies, and establish
our National Park system.
15:41
Democrat Lyndon Johnson
announced the Great Society
15:53
during a commencement
here at Michigan,
15:56
but it was the Republican
President before him,
15:59
Dwight Eisenhower, who launched
the massive government
16:03
undertaking known as the
Interstate Highway System.
16:05
Of course, there have always
been those who've opposed such efforts.
16:10
They argue government
intervention is usually
16:15
inefficient; that it restricts
individual freedom and dampens
16:16
individual initiative.
16:20
And in certain instances,
that's been true.
16:22
For many years, we had a
welfare system that too often
16:25
discouraged people from taking
responsibility for their own
16:27
At times, we've neglected
the role of parents,
16:32
rather than government, in
cultivating a child's education.
16:36
And sometimes regulation fails,
and sometimes their benefits
16:40
don't justify their costs.
16:44
But what troubles me is when
I hear people say that all of
16:48
government is inherently bad.
16:51
One of my favorite signs during
the health care debate was
16:53
somebody who said, "Keep Your
Government Hands Out Of My Medicare" --
16:56
-- which is essentially saying "Keep Government Out Of My
17:12
Government-Run
Health Care Plan."
17:15
When our government is
spoken of as some menacing,
17:21
threatening foreign entity, it
ignores the fact that in our
17:24
democracy, government is us.
17:29
We, the people, hold our --
17:32
We, the people, hold in our
hands the power to choose our
17:40
leaders and change our laws,
and shape our own destiny.
17:43
Government is the police
officers who are protecting our
17:50
communities, and the servicemen
and women who are defending us abroad.
17:55
Government is the roads you
drove in on and the speed limits
18:08
that kept you safe.
18:11
Government is what ensures that
mines adhere to safety standards
18:13
and that oil spills are cleaned
up by the companies that caused them.
18:16
Government is this extraordinary
public university --
18:26
a place that's doing
lifesaving research,
18:30
and catalyzing economic growth,
and graduating students who will
18:32
change the world around
them in ways big and small.
18:36
The truth is, the debate we've
had for decades now between more
18:45
government and less government,
it doesn't really fit the times
18:49
We know that too much government
can stifle competition and
18:55
deprive us of choice
and burden us with debt.
18:58
But we've also clearly seen the
dangers of too little government
19:03
-- like when a lack of accountability on Wall Street
19:07
nearly leads to the collapse
of our entire economy.
19:10
So, class of 2010, what we
should be asking is not whether
19:21
we need "big government"
or a "small government,"
19:24
but how we can create a
smarter and better government.
19:27
Because in an era
of iPods and Tivo,
19:31
where we have more choices
than ever before --
19:36
even though I can't really
work a lot of these things --
19:38
-- but I have 23-year-olds
who do it for me --
19:44
-- government shouldn't
try to dictate your lives.
19:52
But it should give you the
tools you need to succeed.
19:55
Government shouldn't try
to guarantee results,
19:58
but it should guarantee a
shot at opportunity for every
20:00
American who's
willing to work hard.
20:04
So, yes, we can and should
debate the role of government in our lives.
20:10
But remember, as you are asked
to meet the challenges of our
20:19
time, remember that the ability
for us to adapt our government
20:22
to the needs of the age has
helped make our democracy work
20:27
since its inception.
20:30
Now, the second way to keep our
democracy healthy is to maintain
20:34
a basic level of civility
in our public debate.
20:36
These arguments we're having
over government and health care
20:46
and war and taxes -- these
are serious arguments.
20:49
They should arouse
people's passions,
20:54
and it's important for everybody
to join in the debate,
20:57
with all the vigor that the
maintenance of a free people requires.
21:00
But we can't expect to solve our
problems if all we do is tear
21:07
You can disagree with a certain
policy without demonizing the
21:13
person who espouses it.
21:17
You can question somebody's
views and their judgment without
21:19
questioning their motives
or their patriotism.
21:22
Throwing around phrases like
"socialists" and "Soviet-style
21:25
takeover" and "fascist"
and "right-wing nut" --
21:30
-- that may grab headlines,
but it also has the effect of
21:36
comparing our government,
our political opponents,
21:41
to authoritarian,
even murderous regimes.
21:48
Now, we've seen this kind
of politics in the past.
21:54
It's been practiced by both
fringes of the ideological
21:56
spectrum, by the left and the
right, since our nation's birth.
21:59
But it's starting to creep into
the center of our discourse.
22:03
And the problem with it is not
the hurt feelings or the bruised
22:10
egos of the public officials
who are criticized.
22:12
Remember, they signed up for it.
22:15
Michelle always
reminds me of that.
22:16
The problem is that this kind of
vilification and over-the-top
22:22
rhetoric closes the door to
the possibility of compromise.
22:26
It undermines democratic
deliberation.
22:30
It prevents learning
-- since, after all,
22:33
why should we listen to a "fascist," or a "socialist,"
22:35
or a "right-wing nut,"
or a left-wing nut"?
22:38
It makes it nearly impossible
for people who have legitimate
22:43
but bridgeable differences to
sit down at the same table and
22:48
It robs us of a rational
and serious debate,
22:53
the one we need to have about
the very real and very big
22:58
challenges facing this nation.
23:01
It coarsens our culture,
and at its worst,
23:04
it can send signals to the most
extreme elements of our society
23:07
that perhaps violence is
a justifiable response.
23:10
As I found out after a
year in the White House,
23:17
changing this type of
politics is not easy.
23:19
And part of what civility
requires is that we recall the
23:23
simple lesson most of us learned
from our parents: Treat others
23:26
as you would like to be treated,
with courtesy and respect.
23:31
But civility in this age also
requires something more than
23:44
just asking if we can't
just all get along.
23:47
Today's 24/7 echo-chamber
amplifies the most inflammatory
23:51
soundbites louder and
faster than ever before.
23:56
And it's also, however, given
us unprecedented choice.
23:59
Whereas most Americans used to
get their news from the same
24:04
three networks over dinner, or a
few influential papers on Sunday
24:06
morning, we now have the option
to get our information from any
24:10
number of blogs or websites
or cable news shows.
24:13
And this can have both a
good and bad development for democracy.
24:17
For if we choose only to expose
ourselves to opinions and
24:22
viewpoints that are
in line with our own,
24:24
studies suggest that we
become more polarized,
24:28
more set in our ways.
24:30
That will only reinforce and
even deepen the political
24:33
divides in this country.
24:36
But if we choose to actively
seek out information that
24:38
challenges our assumptions
and our beliefs,
24:41
perhaps we can begin to
understand where the people who
24:43
disagree with us
are coming from.
24:46
Now, this requires us to agree
on a certain set of facts to
24:48
That's why we need a vibrant and
thriving news business that is
24:55
separate from opinion
makers and talking heads.
24:58
That's why we need an educated
citizenry that values hard
25:08
evidence and not just assertion.
25:12
As Senator Daniel Patrick
Moynihan famously once said,
25:21
"Everybody is entitled
to his own opinion,
25:24
but not his own facts."
25:26
Still, if you're somebody who
only reads the editorial page of
25:32
The New York Times, try glancing
at the page of The Wall Street
25:35
Journal once in a while.
25:38
If you're a fan of Glenn
Beck or Rush Limbaugh,
25:41
try reading a few columns on
the Huffington Post website.
25:45
It may make your blood boil;
your mind may not be changed.
25:50
But the practice of listening to
opposing views is essential for
25:56
effective citizenship.
25:59
It is essential
for our democracy.
26:03
And so, too, is the practice
of engaging in different
26:11
experiences with
different kinds of people.
26:13
I look out at this class and
I realize for four years at
26:16
Michigan you have been exposed
to diverse thinkers and
26:20
scholars, professors
and students.
26:22
Don't narrow that broad
intellectual exposure just
26:27
because you're leaving here.
26:29
Instead, seek to expand it.
26:32
If you grew up in a big city,
spend some time with somebody
26:35
who grew up in a rural town.
26:38
If you find yourself only
hanging around with people of
26:40
your own race or
ethnicity or religion,
26:42
include people in your circle
who have different backgrounds
26:46
and life experiences.
26:49
You'll learn what it's like to
walk in somebody else's shoes,
26:51
and in the process, you will
help to make this democracy work.
26:54
Which brings me to the last
ingredient in a functioning
27:07
democracy, one that's
perhaps most basic --
27:10
and it's already
been mentioned --
27:14
and that is participation.
27:15
Class of 2010, I understand that
one effect of today's poisonous
27:19
political climate is to push
people away from participation
27:22
If all you see when you turn
on the TV is name-calling,
27:28
if all you hear about is how
special interest lobbying and
27:33
partisanship prevented
Washington from getting
27:35
something done, you
might think to yourself,
27:37
"What's the point of
getting involved?"
27:41
When we don't pay close
attention to the decisions made
27:47
by our leaders, when we fail
to educate ourselves about the
27:49
major issues of the day, when we
choose not to make our voices
27:52
and opinions heard, that's
when democracy breaks down.
27:56
That's when power is abused.
28:00
That's when the most extreme
voices in our society fill the
28:02
void that we leave.
28:05
That's when powerful interests
and their lobbyists are most
28:07
able to buy access and influence
in the corridors of power --
28:09
because none of us are there
to speak up and stop them.
28:12
Participation in public life
doesn't mean that you all have
28:18
to run for public office -- though we could certainly use
28:21
some fresh faces in Washington.
28:24
(laughter and applause)
28:26
But it does mean that you should pay attention and contribute in
28:29
any way that you can.
28:34
Write letters, or make phone
calls on behalf of an issue you
28:38
If electoral politics
isn't your thing,
28:42
continue the tradition so many
of you started here at Michigan
28:45
and find a way to serve your
community and your country --
28:48
an act that will help you
stay connected to your fellow
28:51
citizens and improve the
lives of those around you.
28:54
It was 50 years ago that a young
candidate for president came
28:58
here to Michigan and delivered a
speech that inspired one of the
29:02
most successful service
projects in American history.
29:05
And as John F. Kennedy described the ideals behind what would
29:10
become the Peace Corps, he issued a challenge to the
29:14
students who had assembled in Ann Arbor on that October night:
29:18
"on your willingness to contribute part of your life to
29:23
this country," he said, will depend the answer whether a free
29:27
society can compete.
29:32
I think it can," he said.
29:36
This democracy we have
is a precious thing.
29:40
For all the arguments and all
the doubts and all the cynicism
29:44
that's out there today, we
should never forget that as
29:48
Americans, we enjoy more
freedoms and opportunities than
29:51
citizens in any other
nation on Earth.
29:55
We are free to speak our mind and worship as we please.
29:59
We are free to
choose our leaders,
30:02
and criticize them
if they let us down.
30:04
We have the chance to get an
education, and work hard,
30:11
and give our children
a better life.
30:14
None of this came easy.
30:18
None of this was preordained.
30:20
The men and women who sat in
your chairs 10 years ago and 50
30:24
years ago and 100 years ago
-- they made America possible
30:27
through their toil and their endurance and their imagination
30:31
Their success, and America's
success, was never a given.
30:41
And there is no guarantee that
the graduates who will sit in
30:46
these same seats 10 years from
now, or 50 years from now,
30:50
or 100 years from now, will
enjoy the same freedoms and
30:52
opportunities that you do.
30:56
You, too, will have to strive.
31:00
You, too, will have to push
the boundaries of what seems possible.
31:03
For the truth is, our nation's
destiny has never been certain.
31:10
What is certain -- what
has always been certain --
31:15
is the ability to
shape that destiny.
31:19
That is what makes us different.
31:22
That is what sets us apart.
31:25
That is what makes
us Americans --
31:28
our ability at the end of the
day to look past all of our
31:30
differences and all of our
disagreements and still forge a
31:32
That task is now in your hands,
as is the answer to the question
31:37
posed at this university half a
century ago about whether a free
31:42
society can still compete.
31:46
If you are willing, as past
generations were willing,
31:50
to contribute part of your life
to the life of this country,
31:54
then I, like President
Kennedy, believe we can.
31:59
Because I believe in you.
32:05
Congratulations on
your graduation, 2010.
32:08
May God bless you, and may God
bless the United States of America.
32:10