>> DAVID J. MALAN: Can you hear me, world?
00:32
So in next week's episode we'll
talk about microphone technology.
00:34
But for now, let's begin.
00:38
Hello, world, we are
back, as is my voice.
00:40
And this is CS50 Live.
00:42
>> And boy, do we have a good
show for you this week.
00:44
In particular, we've
got the Heartbleed bug
00:47
that's been all over the news of
late, some stories from students,
00:49
a trip to Vegas, a behind
the scenes tour of Dropbox.
00:52
And I'm hearing, yes, CS50's
own Ramon Galvin is back.
00:56
CS50's Ramon Galvin is in
the studio again today.
01:00
>> But first, some desk lamps.
01:03
Of course desk lamps have been a bit
of a thing this semester in CS50.
01:05
And you may recall Ahmad,
from a previous episode, who
01:08
submitted a video
making his case for why
01:11
he'd like to receive
his own CS50 desk lamp.
01:13
Well, we sent a desk
lamp ultimately to Ahmad.
01:16
And he kindly sent us
this photo of himself
01:18
in Pakistan with a CS50 desk lamp.
01:21
>> Meanwhile, you may recall Lamp
Story, submitted by Eggers in Latvia.
01:24
We sent over a desk
lamp to Latvia as well.
01:27
And pictured here is that desk lamp.
01:29
Finally, you may recall Philip
who didn't just submit a photo,
01:32
but also submitted a video
via which to thank us
01:35
for his desk lamp, which we
sent all the way to Germany.
01:38
Dear David, and dear all of
you amazing people at CS50.
01:44
I'm Phil and I want to thank you
so much for this incredible gift.
01:47
It is unbelievable to
me that you actually
01:52
sent this all the way
over here to Germany.
01:54
Why don't I thank you personally?
01:58
>> Hey, David, I want to thank you
so much for this CS50 desk lamp.
02:01
You can not imagine
what this means to me.
02:05
>> DAVID J. MALAN: Desk lamp?
02:08
OK, I'm going to leave,
but, yeah, thanks.
02:11
DAVID J. MALAN: Now, two of your
classmates actually traveled
02:17
to us to have a chat of late.
02:19
In particular, Amy from Massachusetts
and Jack from Dublin, Ireland,
02:21
came all the way to Sanders Theater
to sit down and talk about CS50
02:25
>> This is Sanders Theater.
02:33
So this is where CS50's
lectures are held.
02:34
Thanks so much for coming to campus.
02:38
Shall we start with the introductions?
02:40
I work on the web and I
live here in Cambridge.
02:43
>> JACK: I'm Jack and I'm
from Dublin, Ireland.
02:46
I'm a junior in high school.
02:49
>> DAVID J. MALAN: And what brings you here
today in particular from so far away?
02:50
JACK: For a visit to Boston.
02:53
>> AMY: How has CS50 evolved
as you've been teaching it?
02:55
>> DAVID J. MALAN: It's definitely
gotten more dramatic over the years.
02:58
We've been filming since 2007, so
we can literally go back in time
03:02
and watch past years, first
lectures in particular.
03:05
And I think the first lecture
in 2007 was pretty much
03:08
me, coming out in front of the class.
03:11
Saying, hello, this is CS50.
03:13
And we dove into the day's material.
03:16
>> All right, so welcome
to Computer Science 50,
03:18
Introduction to Computer Science 1.
03:21
My name is David Malin and I
will be your instructor this--
03:23
>> Now there's music.
03:26
The lights go down.
03:28
We drop down a huge screen.
03:29
There may or may not be
Muppets in a given year.
03:30
And it's funny, because this
has all happened very gradually
03:38
over the years, just a
little bit more each year.
03:42
But the delta, now, between the
first year and the last year
03:44
is actually rather atrocious, just how
different the first five minutes are.
03:47
>> AMY: I'm curious, what do you see
as the differences between the edX
03:51
version and the live course?
03:56
>> DAVID J. MALAN: So curricularly
and technologically CS50
03:59
on campus and CS50x off campus
are fundamentally the same.
04:02
What does differ between the
two is the level of support
04:06
that we're able to provide.
04:09
Even though CS50 has a huge team of
some 100 teaching fellows, course
04:11
assistants, myself, and
our production team--
04:15
we can just barely keep up
with the 700 students on campus
04:18
and the 150 Extension School students
who are local or online themselves.
04:22
So for CS50x, we simply don't have
the support structure of office hours,
04:27
for instance, four nights
a week for several hours.
04:30
JACK: And what do you guys talk about in
office hours that will be different to,
04:33
say, what you have on lectures,
or on sections, or shorts?
04:36
DAVID J. MALAN: On campus
office hours are really
04:39
opportunities for students to
pose questions, one on one,
04:41
with a member of the teaching staff
or even a classmate of theirs nearby.
04:44
And generally wrestle with bugs
that they're having in their codes.
04:48
>> AMY: I think Reddit kind of gives
a reasonable facsimile of an office
04:51
>> DAVID J. MALAN: Agreed, agreed.
04:55
I've been really impressed,
though, with the Reddit community
04:56
and the newcomers to
the group, too-- just
04:59
how eager and hopeful people have been.
05:01
And Reddit definitely lends itself
better, I think, to posting of code
05:03
and having threaded discussions.
05:06
>> JACK: And do you think
people should try,
05:08
if they know they're
doing something wrong
05:10
or it's like, they've implemented--
spent too much time on it,
05:12
think they should stop and start again?
05:15
Or how should they--
05:18
>> DAVID J. MALAN: Take a break, minimally.
05:20
Sometimes, especially for me at least,
as your stress level starts to rise you
05:22
start hacking away and copying
and pasting, forgetting
05:26
what you've already tried.
05:29
It's just time to go to
sleep, or go take a jog,
05:30
or go shower, and just
kind of get some distance.
05:32
And this has happened
many, many times to me
05:35
where I'll be lying there in bed
even, or even driving to work,
05:39
or walking somewhere, kind
of debugging in my head.
05:42
>> And only once you have that distance
and a lot less stress on your shoulders,
05:44
I think, can you realize,
like, oh, I'm an idiot.
05:47
I forgot to call this function,
or initialize some variable.
05:49
>> So as a little surprise if you'd like
to take a look under your CS50 seat
05:54
cushion, a little something awaits you.
05:58
Those were good looks.
06:07
Did we get those looks?
06:08
>> Under their seat cushions, of
course, was a bit more Dropbox space.
06:11
Now you may recall we recently
traveled to Saint Louis, Missouri,
06:14
where we had a unique opportunity
to actually blow glass
06:17
at the Third Degree Glass factory.
06:20
Our host for the day made
this beautiful bowl of glass
06:22
by spinning and spinning it until
you got this beautiful wavy effect.
06:26
And this now lives in our
offices here in Cambridge.
06:29
>> I, on the other hand, made
this big ball of orange glass
06:32
that now sits on my desk.
06:35
But we were in Saint Louis, of
course, for the CS50 hackathon
06:37
in Saint Louis with Launchcode,
where we had an opportunity
06:39
to sit down with a number of your
classmates and hear their CS50 stories.
06:42
>> EZRA: Once I saw computer
coding and the kind of-- that's
06:48
the career that I want to be in.
06:55
And I think that I would
be very good at it.
06:56
>> CHARLES: Well, I've been
job hunting for a while.
07:00
Bachelor of Science,
biomedical engineering.
07:02
It hasn't been going too well.
07:04
So I thought maybe I'd look
into a different field.
07:06
>> KIMBERLY: In Green Bay, Wisconsin
I was a school counselor.
07:09
And I really knew I
wanted to change careers.
07:12
>> SAM: I've heard a lot of
people saying, like, everyone
07:16
should learn how to code.
07:19
Everyone should be exposed to it.
07:20
And before I was just kind
of like, eh, whatever.
07:22
>> AUSTIN: I had taken a semester off.
07:25
And I'm now doing the CS50x program.
07:27
>> KELLI: It's very accessible
to anyone at all.
07:30
>> LEANNE: I've been a
developer in the past.
07:34
But I had a situation and I wanted
to kind of increase my confidence,
07:37
and I wanted to learn
C, and I wanted to learn
07:41
PHP, which I saw that CS50 was teaching.
07:44
AUSTIN: People are really helpful.
07:47
There's definitely more
of a community than you
07:49
would think from an online course.
07:50
>> KELLI: I'm working on my problem
set five, that I just started.
07:52
So I get to do a little forensics.
07:55
>> CHARLES: It has been challenging.
07:59
It's definitely meant
to stretch your limits.
08:01
I'm working on problem set five.
08:04
>> KIMBERLY: My classmate and I are
working on our final project.
08:06
>> SAM: I'm working on my final project.
08:09
I've got two other people working
with me, we're the tri-force of power.
08:11
>> LEANNE: I'm attempting to work on
an iOS app that is a calendar agenda
08:15
application that I wanted to create,
just for my own use, to start out with.
08:21
>> AUSTIN: My final project is
going to be a website that
08:26
is an image and visual repository.
08:28
Basically it's going to have
a listing of helpful phrases
08:31
and sign language for medical personnel.
08:35
>> EZRA: Let's say my final project
was a puppet doing a dance,
08:38
and they asked me, can you make this
puppet to do this dance twice as fast?
08:42
I would be able to go to my code, change
it, save it, compile it, upload it,
08:49
and show them right away that
I can-- that not only did I
08:55
make this final project, I understand.
08:58
I can tweak it however
they want me to tweak it.
09:01
>> CHARLES: I figure once I get
my final project completed
09:03
and some potential
employers have a chance
09:06
to look at that they'll have a
better assessment of whether they
09:08
think I'll be a good fit for them.
09:11
SAM: Now I'm very confident and I'm
learning new stuff all the time.
09:12
It's changed my life.
09:18
>> EZRA: This is really
hard material, especially
09:20
if you're doing this and also
working, and maybe also have a family,
09:24
and maybe also have children,
and maybe also have a mortgage.
09:31
But it's so worth it if
you just put the effort in.
09:35
What you get out is so much more
valuable than the time that you put in.
09:41
DAVID J. MALAN: And
now, this week in tech.
09:47
Odds are you've heard of
the so-called Heartbleed
09:49
bug, which has affected web
servers throughout the world.
09:51
But what is this bug, exactly?
09:53
Well, turns out that many web
servers run software called open
09:55
SSL, where SSL of course
is Secure Sockets Layer.
09:59
And this is the technology that
encrypts traffic between a web browser,
10:02
or client, and a web server.
10:05
Now unfortunately, in
December of 2011, a programmer
10:07
introduced an accidental bug into
the source code for open SSL.
10:10
>> And open SSL unfortunately is
used in so many other products,
10:14
among them the Apache
web server, and others,
10:17
that are hugely popular on the
internet for hosting websites.
10:20
The result of this was that the
following attack is possible.
10:23
As part of open SSL there's a
so-called heartbeat feature,
10:29
whereby a client like a browser
can send a message or a payload,
10:32
which is really just a string,
like hello, to a server.
10:36
And in addition to that
payload it sends a number
10:38
which should be the
length of that payload.
10:40
In the case of hello, it should be five.
10:43
>> Unfortunately, the bug in
open SSL operated as follows.
10:45
It ignored that number.
10:49
And so if you-- rather,
it trusted that number.
10:50
So if you, the client, sent a message
like hello, and not the number 5
10:55
but the number 100, what would happen
is that the server would blindly
10:59
respond to that payload by
echoing back not only hello,
11:03
those 5 bytes, but 95 additional
bytes thereby trusting
11:06
that you were telling the truth when you
said that the payload was in fact 100
11:10
Now why is that problematic?
11:14
>> Well, you may recall
from CS50, of course,
11:16
from memory management that
on the stack and the heap
11:18
are remnants of data paths, when you've
called a function, used a variable,
11:20
those values stay in memory even
if you're no longer actively using
11:24
those chunks of memory.
11:28
So when the server responds not with 5
bites but with 100 bytes, 95 of which
11:29
are not technically supposed
to go back to the client,
11:34
those 95 bytes could contain
passwords, or the server's
11:37
security certificates, or the servers
secret keys, so to speak, all of which
11:40
are used for encryption.
11:45
>> And so ultimately your
information could be handed back
11:46
to some random adversary
on the internet simply
11:49
because your password, or
credit card information,
11:52
or something else that's
sensitive happened
11:54
to be in the web server's memory
at that particular location.
11:56
Now this was a big
deal, because this bug
11:59
affected web servers
throughout the world.
12:01
Among them Amazon Web Services, Box,
Dropbox, Etsy, Flickr, GitHub, Gmail,
12:03
Go Daddy, Google, Instagram,
Minecraft, Netflix, OKCupid, Pinterest,
12:08
SoundCloud, Tumblr, Twitter,
Venmo, Wikipedia, WordPress, Yahoo,
12:11
YouTube-- and those are just
the companies, just some
12:15
of the companies that actually disclosed
that their servers had been running
12:19
the afflicted software and had
only recently, as this past week,
12:22
>> Now it turns out the fix, in source code
for, this Heartbleed bug is actually
12:27
It pretty much boils down
to these two lines of code.
12:32
If payload is greater than
the actual length, return 0.
12:35
Do not return some
potentially disclosing bits.
12:39
Now in reality the lines of
code were a little more complex.
12:42
It looked a bit more like this.
12:45
But this is just some
additional arithmetic
12:47
and there were a few
other lines of code,
12:48
but the fix really was that simple.
12:50
>> And so if you've never
believed in lectures
12:52
when we say that you should always
check the boundaries of your array
12:54
and make sure to check the
lengths of any chunk of memory
12:57
before blindly traversing
through your computer's memory,
13:00
this is what can happen.
13:03
And truly it's been a
globally impactful bug.
13:05
Now what can you yourself do to
learn more and protect yourself?
13:08
Well, head to heartbleed.com,
which is a terrific website that
13:11
explains in a bit more detail exactly
what the threat is, how folks have
13:14
responded, what
software's been affected,
13:18
and how you can defend yourself.
13:20
But it pretty much boils down
to this-- change your passwords,
13:21
arguably on most any
website you know if unsure
13:25
whether that particular
website was affected.
13:27
>> Because one of the scariest
things about this bug
13:29
is that it's not so much auditable.
13:31
It's not clear if, even
over the past two years,
13:33
a server was vulnerable, if your
information was indeed compromised.
13:36
So as is the case
generally with security,
13:39
the best approach is paranoia
and change any passwords
13:42
on websites that are
particularly sensitive to you.
13:45
But head to that URL there
for even more detail.
13:48
>> Now in other news, Mark
Zuckerberg recently posted this.
13:50
I'm excited to announce
that we've agreed
13:53
to acquire Oculus VR, the leader
in virtual reality technology.
13:55
Now virtual reality is
an interesting thing
13:59
that's beginning to gain
a bit more traction.
14:01
It generally involves
putting on a pair of goggles
14:03
that might look like these inside
of which are a pair of lenses that
14:05
allow you to see a computer screen
right up close to your face.
14:08
And on that computer screen could
be anything, the inside of a house,
14:12
the outside of the house, a
virtual world inside of a game.
14:15
And the result is an incredibly
immersive opportunity
14:18
to feel as though you're actually
someplace that you're actually not.
14:22
I, for instance, might
be in a conference room
14:25
when really I think I'm in
a Tron-like virtual world.
14:27
And indeed, I had an opportunity.
14:31
I haven't personally played with
Oculus, but I did visit our friends
14:32
in Seattle, Washington,
recently at Valve software, who
14:35
were working on a very
similar VR technology.
14:38
And I was very fortunate
to have the opportunity
14:40
to put on their pair of
goggles for 60 seconds of this.
14:43
>> Now, CS50's own Dan Coffey
also had an opportunity
15:48
to take a trip recently to
Mountain View, California,
15:51
where he sat down with our
friends at Dropbox, among them
15:53
CS50's own former head teaching
fellow Thomas Carriero,
15:56
who's been responsible for
all of that Dropbox space
15:59
underneath your seat cushions.
16:02
Thomas very kindly opened the doors
of Dropbox and gave us an exclusive
16:03
behind the scenes of what
it's like to work at Dropbox
16:07
and daresay live at Dropbox.
16:10
>> THOMAS CARRIERO: Hi, I'm Thomas
Carriero, former CS50 head TF.
16:14
We're here at the Dropbox headquarters
in San Francisco, California.
16:19
I'm going to show you on a tour.
16:22
So this balloon right here,
this green check mark,
16:27
is the balloon that we put on your
desk when you first join the company.
16:30
And the idea is that the balloon
will stay kind of up there as long
16:34
as you're a new hire.
16:37
So the balloon of course loses
helium over time and by the time
16:38
the balloon is dead
you're no longer a noob.
16:42
This takes a couple of months to
happen because these are really, really
16:47
expensive balloons.
16:51
We think we might keep the green check
mark balloon business in business.
16:52
>> Cool, so this right here is AT&T Park.
16:57
This is where the San
Francisco Giants play.
17:00
We actually have a Dropbox box suite,
one of our other awesome amenities,
17:02
just across the way.
17:08
So I'm standing by this
really cool light display.
17:09
So what's going on here is
we're getting real time data
17:11
about what's happening
in our Mailbox app.
17:13
Each of the colors corresponds
to a different action.
17:16
>> And so as users are doing
these actions, these lights
17:19
are lighting up with those colors to
kind of let us know what's going on.
17:23
Sometimes if stuff is going wrong, the
colors will all start to be one color
17:26
and we know that something
bad is happening.
17:30
So this is kind of one
of the ways that we
17:33
keep track of what's
going on in Mailbox.
17:34
>> Cool, so let's see what's
for dinner tonight.
17:39
Looks like we have eight hour
smoked beef brisket right here.
17:42
And right here is my favorite
station, the Indian station.
17:46
It's an open face samosa chop today.
17:49
Well, I guess that was
my favorite station
17:53
but this is my other favorite station.
17:55
>> This is the pizza station.
17:57
So they always make different kinds of
pizza with our pizza oven right there.
17:58
Looks like they're making a Sicilian
pizza, which is one of my favorites.
18:02
All right, so the chef told me
that they are freshly made Ho Hos.
18:06
I told him I was going to wait
until after I'd eaten my dinner
18:10
but I'm definitely going to
have one of those tonight.
18:13
OK, I'm going to have mine now.
18:15
>> So this is kind of the bonus station
that's outside of the tech shop.
18:23
For lunch we have Mexican
food here and sushi here.
18:26
And for dinner we have
some kind meat delicious.
18:29
Looks like roasted pork loin tonight.
18:34
Get a close up on that.
18:37
Cool, so this is our design area.
18:40
This is where we design
a bunch of the products.
18:42
We have lots of fun
poster boards and stuff,
18:44
with kind of all the mocks
that we're working on.
18:47
We also have along the
ground a bunch of the mocks
18:50
that we've been working
on over the years.
18:53
So you can get a close
up of that in a second.
18:56
>> But this sign is one of my
favorite things about Dropbox.
18:58
So this sign actually
came from the old office.
19:01
And our slogan is, it just works.
19:03
But if you look closely, there's
a subliminal message in the sign.
19:05
>> So one of my favorite parts about
Dropbox are these vending machines.
19:10
Instead of having chips or
soda or anything like that,
19:14
we actually have electronics.
19:17
So if you need a new trackpad, or
a new keyboard, or some headphones,
19:19
all you need to do is swipe
your badge right here.
19:24
Type in the number and then
the out comes your electronics.
19:27
Thanks so much for joining
me on this tour of Dropbox.
19:30
It's been really fun showing you around.
19:33
>> I'm going to close this out
with the way we close out
19:35
all of our all hands meetings.
19:37
This is a special chant we do.
19:40
Can I get some help here?
19:41
One, two, three-- Dropbox!
19:44
It's usually much cooler than that.
19:47
DAVID J. MALAN: Now if
you'd like to visit Dropbox,
19:57
head to Mountain View, California, hop
on Route 101 north to San Francisco,
20:00
where they actually are.
20:04
Now we've also had an
opportunity recently
20:06
to travel to Las Vegas,
Nevada for the NAB show,
20:07
the National Association
for Broadcasters show,
20:11
which brings together some
100,000 people interested
20:13
in audio and video and
technology more generally
20:16
to talk about the very
latest and greatest.
20:18
>> CS50's own Ramon Galvin took
this trip and brought with him
20:21
a camera crew in order to this
footage from the show's floor.
20:24
RAMON GALVIN: Hello, world.
20:28
Do I have to say my name?
20:32
>> CAMERAMAN: Correspondent in the field .
20:34
RAMON GALVIN: Can I get
a lower third of that?
20:37
Correspondent in field.
20:39
>> CAMERAMAN: Senior.
20:43
RAMON GALVIN: There you go.
20:44
I know, but I have to
do it. [INAUDIBLE].
20:53
>> Now's my prima donna pose.
21:14
DAVID J. MALAN: And
they keep mentioning 4K.
21:35
What is 4K exactly?
21:37
>> RAMON GALVIN: That's a
really good question.
21:40
>> DAVID J. MALAN: Cut to
a clip explaining 4K.
21:43
My name is David Malan.
21:54
RAMON GALVIN: I'm Ramon Galvin.
21:55
DAVID J. MALAN: And we're here
at NAP, the National Association
21:57
of Broadcasters conference
in Las Vegas, Nevada.
21:59
But why are we here?
22:01
RAMON GALVIN: I don't know.
22:02
I don't know, David.
22:03
>> DAVID J. MALAN: That was pretty good.
22:05
>> RAMON GALVIN: Probably not.
22:08
DAVID J. MALAN: We're back,
as is CS50's own Ramon
22:10
Galvin, who you may recall
from last week's episode.
22:12
Ramon, so glad you are indeed back.
22:16
>> RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad I
still have a job, David.
22:17
>> DAVID J. MALAN: So let's
address the elephant
22:19
that was in the room in
Las Vegas, namely 4K.
22:21
I've heard about this in the context
of TVs and computer monitors,
22:22
>> RAMON GALVIN: So it's a resolution.
22:27
Whenever you're watching a
walk through video or a lecture
22:28
you get what we call 1080p video.
22:31
What that means that the
video is 1,000 pixels tall.
22:33
>> DAVID J. MALAN: Or 1080.
22:37
>> RAMON GALVIN: Or 1080.
22:38
Or roughly 2,000 pixels wide.
22:39
Now 4K is 4,000 pixels wide, roughly,
and roughly 2,000 pixels tall.
22:42
DAVID J. MALAN: OK.
22:49
So that's kind of like having
a grid of four 1080p monitors
22:50
right in front of you.
22:53
>> RAMON GALVIN: Exactly.
22:55
DAVID J. MALAN: OK, so that's all
fine and good but why is this useful?
22:55
>> RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad I asked you
to ask me that question, David.
22:59
>> DAVID J. MALAN: It's
on the teleprompter.
23:01
>> RAMON GALVIN: So there's
a documentarian named
23:03
Errol Morris that actually
makes use of 4K technology.
23:04
Ordinarily to shoot an
interview, which he usually does,
23:08
he would have to either use multiple
cameras to get a zoomed in shot
23:10
or a zoomed out shot, or
shoot the interview twice
23:14
to get the same zoomed
in, zoomed out shot.
23:17
However, now he's using a 4K
camera to shoot one huge 4K shot.
23:19
And then when he's editing,
artificially cropping that shot.
23:25
DAVID J. MALAN: And
zooming in, essentially,
23:30
to give you still 1080p but only
some of the pixels from the 4K image.
23:31
>> RAMON GALVIN: Exactly, giving
him multiple camera shots
23:35
out of that one original camera shot.
23:38
DAVID J. MALAN: Interesting.
23:40
So how could we make
use of this for CS50?
23:41
>> RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad you asked
me that question, too, David.
23:43
Because I shot the walk through
videos with Zamyla last semester.
23:46
And for those videos we would
have to run through the walk
23:50
through once with a zoomed out shot.
23:53
And then I'd have to adjust the
camera to get a zoomed in shot.
23:55
And then we'd run through it again,
running through it two times.
23:59
With a 4K camera we can cut
our production time in half.
24:03
DAVID J. MALAN: I see.
24:05
So that should be quite exciting
for us, then, this fall.
24:06
RAMON GALVIN: Exactly.
24:09
DAVID J. MALAN: Well, from
the looks of the video
24:10
it sounds like it was a
pretty exhausting trip.
24:11
It sounds like you didn't
really have much time to relax.
24:13
RAMON GALVIN: Not one bit.
24:16
DAVID J. MALAN: Well,
that's it for CS50 Live.
24:20
Thanks so much to this
week's contributors.
24:22
Thanks so much to the
team behind the camera.
24:23
Thanks so much to our correspondent--
24:25
RAMON GALVIN: Senior.
24:27
DAVID J. MALAN: Senior
correspondent in the field.
24:28
>> RAMON GALVIN: And this is
something, I don't know what.
24:32
>> DAVID J. MALAN: It was
our dress rehearsal.
24:35
So that all sounds great.
24:38
Bigger TVs, more
pixels, more resolution.
24:39
But why is this actually useful?
24:42
>> RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad you
asked that question, David.
24:43
>> DAVID J. MALAN: I'm glad you asked--
I'm glad I asked you to ask me that.
24:45
>> RAMON GALVIN: No, I say I'm
glad you asked me the question.
24:48
And then you say, well
it's in the prompter.
24:50
I'm glad I asked you to
ask me that question.
24:52
DAVID J. MALAN: Well, it's
in the prompter there.
24:54
RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad you--
24:56
DAVID J. MALAN: I think it's
funnier if you just say,
24:56
I'm glad I asked you to
ask me that question.
24:57
Because it's kind of a play
on what you would expect.
24:59
>> RAMON GALVIN: OK.
25:02
I'm glad you asked me to
ask that question, David.
25:02
There's a documentarian.
25:05
>> DAVID J. MALAN: I'm glad
I asked you to ask me.
25:06
RAMON GALVIN: I'm glad I asked
you to ask me that question.
25:08
>> [MUSIC- CAKE, "THE DISTANCE"]
25:11